My parents have 4 cats all rescues. Their most recent came from a high kill shelter and was saved a day before "execution." He had a horrible upper respirotory infection and my parents spent almost 600 saving him. He has started pooping in thier basement. (no pee) But he will also go in the litter box at times. He wont poop anywhere else but in the basemet. (Long story how they figured out it was him doing this and nnot the other cats.)
I spoke with my best friend who is a vet. She suggested adding more litter boxes and using this "cat attract" stuff in the litter. My parents did that and he is still going in these 2 spots in the basemet. (My mom refuses to put a litter box in these exact spots because all her grandkids play there.)
There is a litter box in the storage room that he uses though. My dad is losing patience with him bc he is picking up poop and cleaning carpet everyday. He thinks he may have been put at the shelter bc of this issue. He has agreed to keep him but has him locked in a room in the basement which is very large and has lots of things to play on/with.
I feel bad that he is locked in there but he never goes outside the box in there and my dad goes to visit him a couple times a day when he is fed. I am telling myself this is better than him ending up in a shelter and being unadoptable bc of the pooping issue.
My dad is going to try him out of his room again in a week to see how he does. What do you guys think about this? Is it horribly cruel to keep him locked in a room like that?
Re: Cat question
A few other things to maybe consider:
Where are the other boxes at? Some cats do not want to use boxes that are too close to the place the eat. Also some cats do not like places that are too busy. Maybe that is why he like the storage room - it is quite and he has privacy.
Another suggestion is two boxes side by side. Some cats want to be able to choose the cleanest box.
My sister had a cat that pooped in the basement for awhile after they moved to their house, but over time it slowly stopped and now always uses the box. She has no idea why, but I guess just time? Until recently, I had two cats (one passed away) but luckily this was not an issue we dealt with. But a lot of people must because it is covered in both of my cat books. I think if your Dad visits the cat frequently, and he is willing to give him a chance to roam the house again, that he is doing the best he can. It is great that your parents were willing to adopt so many!