baby girl names....

Awilburn23

Madison or Makayla

tortuga47

Madison

theimpossibleastronaut

Both names are NMS but I'd pick Madison. I don't like the spelling of Makayla.

heatbria

I like Makayla but I don't like the way it's spelled either way ;(  It looks funny to me so I say Madison.

Moxie27

neither.

gun to my head, makayla.

Jessilovee

Madison

elfchique

Joy2611:

Neither?

 

Um, okay then Michaela.  But geezoman spell it right.

this.  

af1274

RiverSong82:

Both names are NMS but I'd pick Madison. I don't like the spelling of Makayla.

This. 

MrsLilac337

justAphase:

Madison. If you go with Michaela please spell it correctly. 

Suggestion: Madeleine. Similar but so much prettier.  

 

I really like this suggestion!

OP, Madison gmv, but if spelled Michaela, I like Michaela better. 

dande2129

justAphase:

 Suggestion: Madeleine. Similar but so much prettier.  

This. I love it way better than your other two choices. 

kmdoh77

justAphase:

Madison. If you go with Michaela please spell it correctly. 

Suggestion: Madeleine. Similar but so much prettier.  

This. If you go with Makayla your daughter will have a lifelong frustration every time she has to spell out her name for someone.

mamahawk12

Neither, sorry  

happygril

Makayla!!!! 

 I'm not a huge a fan of Madison, but it's not terrible.  I've heard worse.

I think Makayla is a very cute name!  And in this case I think the spelling is okay, especially if you plan on ever using Kayla as a nn.  Otherwise, I would pick the traditional spelling.

kmichln

Definitely Madison

jennyann28

meaknigh:

Neither, sorry  

Agreed.  

alohamora