Which spelling

MrandMrsHull

We have decided on Charlotte. We have also decided on nn of Charlie. Let me note that I realize these names are both common the popularity does not bother me and we don't know any kids with these names. 

 I do not like any alternative nn like Char or Lotte, we are set on Charlie

DH wants to girl up Charlie by spelling it Charley or Charlea....I say stay with the original and though more boyish Charlie as I am not a fan of odd spellings. WDYT? 

JRanalli10

I would girl up the nickname. My daughters name is rylan and we were going to spell it more girly such as rilyn or rylin.  However, we went with normal spelling and now people assume she is a boy or get her name wrong. 

pammeelala

I love the NN Charlie for Charlotte, my hubby hates it, which means Charlotte is permanently off the list, long or short.

Spell it Charlie

mamahawk12

I think Charlotte is adorable. I knew a Charlie in HS and always thought her name was adorable. I prefer the traditional spelling Charlie - however, I don't think Charley is terrible. Not a fan of Charlea though, it looks made-up to me.

PrincessFiona9

meaknigh:

I think Charlotte is adorable. I knew a Charlie in HS and always thought her name was adorable. I prefer the traditional spelling Charlie - however, I don't think Charley is terrible. Not a fan of Charlea though, it looks made-up to me.

This.

Jazzyashes84

Joy2611:

I think Charlie is a boy's name.  But, if you must, spell it correctly: Charlie.

ladymk

Charli maybe?

ljtvirkus

Joy2611:

I think Charlie is a boy's name.  But, if you must, spell it correctly: Charlie.

Ditto

SunnyD2011

I like Charlotte. I don't know why every name needs to have a nn too. It is perfect as is.

blu-eyedwife

Charlie

strawberrytree

I've known two girls named Charlotte who went by Charlie. One spelled it Charlee and the other spelled it Charli, and I think both are kinda cute for a girl. I don't like either of your DH's options- Charlea looks made-up and I think Charley looks like a boy. I'd go with Charli or Charlie. 

da731

I think Charlie is cute.

My brain wants to pronounce Charley as "Shar-lee" and Charlea as "Shar-lay" though there's really no rhyme nor reason that I would attribute an "sh" sound to the "Ch" when Charlie stays the same.

Hmmm.  

ObLaDi

Definitely keep it Charlie.

This will be a common nickname for girls in her generation. Other spellings just look cutesy/uneek.

MAMAxB

mj.reilly:

Joy2611:

I think Charlie is a boy's name.  But, if you must, spell it correctly: Charlie.

This is my opinion as well.

Mine as well