Dylan for a girl?

StarLightStar22

We are having twin girls and trying to figure out names! We defiantly like Haley (yes I know very popular now) but we are looking at Dylan Brooke for a girl? Too boyish? Honest opinions are great

BlueRidge8

Not at fan.... at all.

SpruceGrouse

I don't like it much even for a boy but especially not for a girl.  Haley and Brooke are nice though.  I am really not a fan of giving girls boy names, just NMS.

mlf625

I don't think it's terrible for a girl, but if you're having twin girls, why give one a feminine name and the other a masculine name?  I don't think that's very fair to the masculinely named girl.  It's not that I think twin names should match, but I wouldn't go so wildly opposite, either.

I much prefer Haley and Brooke. 

VTFutureMrs

I like Haley, but I definitely do not like Dylan. 

StarLightStar22

mlf625:

I don't think it's terrible for a girl, but if you're having twin girls, why give one a feminine name and the other a masculine name?  I don't think that's very fair to the masculinely named girl.  It's not that I think twin names should match, but I wouldn't go so wildly opposite, either.

I much prefer Haley and Brooke. 

Very good thought! I really never thought of it that way! Thats why I asked ! Any suggestions of twin girls names that go well with Haley?? Id like to keep Brooke as a middle name!

Ripli

I think Dylan for a girl is fine, I don't think Brooke is particularly girly either though. Ralph Laurens daughter is called Dylan and wasn't one of the Charlies Angels called Dylan too?  

 

JuneMagnolia

I personally don't like boy names on girls, so I can't say I love Dylan. However, of all the boy names I've seen for girls, this one is definitely not the worst. I do think Haley and Brooke sound nice together though! 

susieandmarty

What about Michelle Brooke.  I think it works well with Hailey and is very feminine.  I am not a big fan of Dylan for a girl

apc1929

I really like Dylan Brooke..   I'm not so opposed to boyish names for girls though like a lot of other posters on this board

LMS05

Please no. It's terrible.

alohamora

If you told me your twins were Haley and Dylan, I would think they were a girl and a boy.  Names that might be your style and go with Haley and mn Brooke...

Audrey Brooke
Caitlin Brooke
Chloe Brooke
Evelyn Brooke
Harper Brooke
Isla Brooke
Juliana Brooke
Lila Brooke
Lillian Brooke
Macy Brooke
Molly Brooke
Nora Brooke
Olivia Brooke
Piper Brooke
Sadie Brooke

checkrdtop

I like it.

kbradshaw9

Love it.

Livs-mama

I dont find the name Dylan feminine at all.  I would think you had a boy and a girl.

Brodyrox30

Don't do it. Dylan is and always will be, a boys' name.

love_melongtime

mlf625:

I don't think it's terrible for a girl, but if you're having twin girls, why give one a feminine name and the other a masculine name?  I don't think that's very fair to the masculinely named girl.  It's not that I think twin names should match, but I wouldn't go so wildly opposite, either.

I much prefer Haley and Brooke. 

She will forever wonder why her parents gave her the manly name.

ashleah83

I think Dylan Brooke is a beautiful name!

forensicmama

Yuck.

RyeRye789

I really like it

alandals

Yuck.. Dylan is a boy's name and I don't even like it for a boy.

I like Haley though. 

JesseKhloe&Me

Very cute I love it. If DH liked it, it would probably be DD's name. Adorable paired with Brooke also.

Waiting4Fred

I agree that it sounds like a boy/girl combo.

FMIL&MOB

Even if I liked it for a girl's name, which I do not, it is mean to have one twin name be a question her whole life. Even if Hailey was once considered a male name, too.

Hope you reconsider.

Darcy, Natalie, Ashley, Savannah