Review my short list....

KChicago

Ok here are the finalists, brutal honesty please....

Elizabeth (Betsy)

Caroline

Violet

Juliet

Penelope (Penny)

Macy

geezbby09

I LOVE Penelope & Violet they are both on my list:)

forensicmama

Oh I really love your list.  I would personally consider using Juliet or Elizabeth nn Betsy!!! Those are my faves. Caroline, Violet and Penelope are gorgeous classics! Great list.The only name I wouldn't use is Macy.

erinms

I like all of them except Macy.  It is too cutesy for me.

Caroline is classic but a little boring, IMO.

My favorites are Betsy, Violet and Penny.

Great list! 

JaysonandKristin

Caroline is one of the most beautiful names ever, IMHO.  

iteachk

We have adorable neighbors named Penelope (Penny), Violet, and Macy (not siblings.) 

Juliet and Violet are on my short list.  LOVE them.

FemmeNat01

I love your list.

My favourite would be Caroline or Juliet. I love Elizabeth and Violet a lot as well. Penelope is cute. Macy is NMS.

Nanna

The only name on your list that I dislike is Macy.  I honestly love all the rest!  Betsy isn't my favorite nn for Elizabeth, but I do think it's cute.

ckmommy

I agree with the pp's that your list is great except for Macy. Macy is a cute little girl name but is hard to visualize on a grown woman.

SugarQueen101

KChicago:

Ok here are the finalists, brutal honesty please....

Elizabeth (Betsy)

Caroline

Violet

Juliet

Penelope (Penny)

Macy

I wouldn't consider myself brutal, but here goes nothing:

My favorite is Juliet...classic & feminine. I don't know any Juliet's. Caroline is also very pretty, but I know many of those. Macy is spunky & interesting, a good name. Violet is not my style...I guess I just wouldn't want to be named after a color or flower, but that's just me. I'm not a fan of Penelope, but I do like sound of Penny...but it also holds the potential to be an easy target for teasing.

Elizabeth is great, but I wouldn't want to be called Betsy. That's a very popular name for a cow!!! Maybe her nickname could be Lizzy, Beth, Liz...anything but Betsy ;-)

katekat8721

I do NOT like Betsy at all, I LOVE Violet, and the rest are just ok. 

iLikeSloths

Elizabeth (Betsy) - I like Elizabeth but really dislike the nn Betsy.  I prefer Liz, Beth, or Eliza for a nn.

Caroline - LOVE it, classic and feminine

Violet - like it

Juliet - like it

Penelope (Penny) - strongly dislike

Macy - It's okay, but it reminds me of Teen Mom or the store Macy's.

magsugar13

Love Elizabeth ...HATE Betsy ugh

Caroline is nice but oh some popular at the moment

Violet is ok

Juliet is my fav on the list

Penelope...one of those names that makes me cringe

Macy great store

kmv68

Wow, you can't go wrong! 

I LOVE Juliet but my husband said "no"!

taggiecb

Elizabeth- not a fan, definately not a fan of Betsy.  But where I live there are a lot of middle aged, poorly dressed/done up women named Elizabeth, so it has a negative connotation with me personally.

Caroline - LOVE!!! was on my short girl list

Violet - really like, haven't really considered it, but I think it's really nice

Juiliet - reminds me of Juilie, and I find that name too common

Penelope - super cute, and fun.  I like it, but it seems very peppy to me.  Not a bad thing, just an observation.

Macy - meh, I know a couple who named their oldest Macy, didn't think it was a real name then, and still don't really know what to think about it.  Her full name is Macy Daisy Rose (then last name)  When I hear that name all I can think of is her full name.

scoutkate

I LOVE Betsy (obviously--see siggy), and Caroline is another of my favorite names.  The rest are also good except for Macy--not a fan. 

Ashnmike528

My favorite from your list is Caroline, absolutely beautiful and timeless!

MarshaBrady

I like them all except Macy.

CactusGirl

Elizabeth (Betsy) - Elizabeth is such a pretty, classic name. And, I really do like Betsy as a nn!!

Caroline - I don't know why, but I never know if this is pronounced Caro-line or Caro-lynn

Violet - OK, NMS

Juliet - Love this name! It would be on my list of names, but it completely clashes with my last name.

Penelope (Penny) - I really like this too

Macy - Like, even though my parents' dog's name is Lacy and it kind of reminds me of that... of course not everyone would have that connection, lol.

I think you have a great list of names here, good luck narrowing it down!

starsjaime

Elizabeth - Okay, but hate Betsy.

Caroline - Classic and beautiful

Violet - Love.

Juliet - LOVE, this is my favorite of your names.  It was on my list, but husband vetoed it.

Penelope - Very nice, but not a fan of Penny.

Macy - Not a fan of at all.  reminds me of macy's to much.  Seems like a 'cheap' kind of name.   

melissa721

I like Macy the best.

ravenorchid

I love Violet, Juliet, and Penelope. I think Elizabeth and Caroline are a bit common for my taste and I'm not a fan of Macy. I just think of the store.

RNOHIO

I really like:

Elizabeth (Betsy)

Caroline

Violet

Penelope (Penny)

 

I like that people are using the "classic" names again.

soldiersgrl3

LOVE Caroline and Macy

atack

I like most of them!  LOVE Love Juliet, but spelled Juliette.  And  I am a fan of Caroline.

kbratton2king

I don't care for any of these but if I HAD to choose my fave it'd be Penelope.

Elizabeth is more of a mn to me.

I'm OVER Caroline, Violet, Juliet and Penelope on this board.

Macy makes me think of Teen Mom or the dept store.

WifeofaMarine

LOVE Juliet. I also like Elizabeth (hate the nickname Betsy though) and Caroline. The others are NMS.