Coming out of lurking ...
sha-teed as it is pronounced is a real deal name. Quite a few Haitian children at the school where my husband taught have this name. Unfortunate? Yes. True? 100%.
I wanted to post this since today alone I say 2 seperate threads where ppl are downright certain its fake. Let me assure you, its real.
Re: Sh!thead
Heavens to Murgatroyd Blog
Unofficial Baby Names Sticky Note: New and Old| Local Bumpie Website
It is usually a friend of the relative. DH is a close enough degree of removal that I'd be convinced. Assuming OP is telling the truth, why would her DH make that up?
I've done a great deal of searching for this name on the internet. I've found several sources that claim it is a popular name in Pakistan, but this is the very first time I've heard of it being used in Haiti. I've never found definitive proof of either--no newspaper reports, baby name databases, or actual people who claim it's their name.
It should also be noted there are several men and boys on Facebook with the name(s) Shi Thead (and Shi Theed), but not one with just Sh!thead. I think it's likely that there are Pakistani families here in the States that are still using the name, but they're obviously choosing to spell it differently to avoid the social stigma.
What makes this name an Urban Legend is the stories that go along with it. You say your husband has met several little Sh!theads and I take you at your word; I don't think it's impossible. However, I do think there is a difference between individuals from cultures that have traditionally used this name and all the dozens of people who claim to know someone who has met/knows a Sh!thead here in the States.
Do you know that we have asked dozens of people to produce some kind of proof (anything official, even a photograph) that they know or have met a Sh!thead and not one can do it? I would even be willing to bet money you're not going to come back with any kind of proof either . . .
Until I see something to change my mind, all evidence seems to suggest Sh!thead is just another legend.
I'm just making the observation that it is never the person who has the name or actually knows the person with the name. It could be true, but I find it odd that it's always someone who knows someone, etc. I don't know why people make this stuff up. I guess they think it's funny.
ETA: Also, the people who posts the urban legend names on this board typically post and never return so that is a bit suspicious too.
Exactly what I was thinking.
Merde!