Did you even attempt to clean toys between baby 1 and baby2? Most of our "baby" toys are still out and DD occasionally plays with them. I feel like our whole house is probably covered w/ the same germs, and DD will immediately "contaminate" the toys again, so it's probably not worth even trying....but should I? Did you?
Re: Cleaning toys, etc for #2???
I am only cleaning soft items like seat covers, boppy, playmat and the stuffed toys that go with it. Even though I put them away clean I will also rewash the burp cloths, tiny bibs, sleepers etc...just so they are fresh.
Random toys that lay around the house and in toy boxes I am not going to worry about.