it sure would make our job as shower planners a lot easier. We are planning a sprinkle for a friend who is having a girl this time and has 1.5 year old son. She already has major gear and furniture but just wants linens, clothes, diapers and other necessities for the girl. She doesn't want to end up with 50 million blankets although she specifically wants pink blankets, she wants a set number of diaper cloths, she wants to make sure she has outfits in different sizes. It all sounds reasonable to me but she doesn't know how we (the planners) should get the message out there. It would be so much easier if she just registered but will the etiquette police come a knockin? I say she should get what she needs and wants if she is having a sprinkle rather than end up having to make a lof of returns (I know from experience that this is a PITA during your first few months with a newborn).
Re: I know registering for sprinkles are tacky but...
I think requesting specific gifts unless asked for a sprinkle or any shower for that matter is incredibley tacky. She gets what she gets. She can try to return anything she doesn't want.
So unless someone asks you or her what it is she wants I wouldn't register or try to spread the word. If she's having a girl chances are she will wind up with a ton of pink stuff anyways without even asking. People love buying pink stuff for girls.
~Benjamin Franklin
DS dx with celiac disease 5/28/10
she's in my church and because there are so many women in the same age range it's going to be well attended (not just family and close friends). We just love to throw showers at my church! I think the audience is mixed but I will recommend that she err on the side of practicality and just register. We (the hostesses) will be relieved and hopefully the guests won't talk about her or she just won't care.
~EDD Nov 18, 2017 with my IUI success story~
[spoiler]
We are doing a sprinkle for my sister this weekend. We added this poem to the invite.
If a gift you wish to bring,
Please remember this one thing,
As this is Baby Number Two
This simple thing we ask of you,
Most they have, but a few they need
Smaller items like diapers and bottles to feed,
Clothes, sweet and pretty, they?ll sure bring a smile
As Katelyn is sure to be cruising in style!
I would think a group like that would appreciate the guidelines of a registry because they won't be as likely as a close family group to coordinate their buying with each other or feel really confident about what to get.
And a registry is also a way to demonstrate only wanting the less-expensive gifts.