I bought one of those pacifiers that when you drop them the cover closes. They looked very close to the mam ones. Silly me, Liam took one look at it and wouldnt have anything to do with it.

Am I stuck with this 4.99 pacifier or can I return it?

[color=#FF0000]Mom to 5 girls 23,22,18,9,7 and one sweet Wonderboy almost 4[/color]
The Chaos of Six!
Re: Can you return an opened pacifier?
[color=#FF0000]Mom to 5 girls 23,22,18,9,7 and one sweet Wonderboy almost 4[/color]
The Chaos of Six!
This.
I returned open bottles to Wal-Mart once. We hadn't used them, but they wouldn't have been able to tell that. They pretty much take back anything, as far as I can tell.
[color=#FF0000]Mom to 5 girls 23,22,18,9,7 and one sweet Wonderboy almost 4[/color]
The Chaos of Six!
I would try. Just make sure you let them know that you used it so they defect it out and don't re-package it and put it on the sales floor.
I bought something once that had clearly already been used and returned. Gross.