For us we tried to do both at the same time. At first she went poop in the potty and then after a couple sucessful attempts she stopped. When I finally decided to ditch the Pull Ups cause they weren't helping things rather making them worse, she had 2 accidents in her panties and that was enough to get her to go in the potty. She is a real private person so we let her go alone and have the door shut. So far it's been working like a charm and she no longer is holding it in. GL!
Re: Pooping on the potty
For us we tried to do both at the same time. At first she went poop in the potty and then after a couple sucessful attempts she stopped. When I finally decided to ditch the Pull Ups cause they weren't helping things rather making them worse, she had 2 accidents in her panties and that was enough to get her to go in the potty. She is a real private person so we let her go alone and have the door shut. So far it's been working like a charm and she no longer is holding it in. GL!