Caroline or Eleanor?

Steeplechaser

Any thoughts, or are they too old fashioned?

 

LyndseylovesHugh

I love Caroline!  Eleanor is NMS, but still a nice name.  They are both very classic, I think they are "old fashioned" but I do not think that is a negative thing.

PhilsWife07

Caroline, hands down.

MaryYVR

I vote Caroline :-)

Temp984666312503071

Caroline hands down.

Eleanor is okay.  I can appreciate that it is a classic but I think it sounds a little drab.

ivs112

Love Caroline!

Ms Molly

Love them both!

mjlewis101

I'm going to go against everyone else and vote Eleanor! I'm biased though. While I think it IS a bit old fashioned and drab...it is my DH's grandmother's name and we love the modern shorter versions of either Ellie or Elle.

Mesassa

I love Caroline! Eleanor doesn't really do anything for me, but that's just me.

PunkyBooster

Love them both.

rach2100

Definitely Caroline

Quizzle

I like both, but Eleanor is the winner for me.

Calabaza78

You can't go wrong with either!  Those were my top 2 girl name choices, but, I'm having a boy.

KeriMichaelMarie

love Eleanor

MontyMrs

LOVE Caroline, I just like Eleanor but I think it would be pretty with the nickname Elle or Ella

lovemytwoboys

Eleanor

Camok87

Both names are pretty, but Caroline is my favourite of the two

lilygirl

love love caroline!!

clairej

Not too old-fashioned. Both are beautiful.

forensicmama

Eleanor is just about my FAVORITE name girl's next to my daughter's name. Caroline is also a beautiful name!

Tiger80

I love Eleanor, Nell as a nn!