What do you think of these boots? PIP

Yodajo

I like these boots, but I can't decide which color to get.  WDTY and which color would you get?

 

debs1018

I like them, and since black is not an option, I would go with the brown.

Yodajo

They have them in black, but my winter coat is brown and I hate mixing black and brown together.

leiann2003

I would get the brown.

Angela814

Not a fan, but I still haven't hopped on the Uggs craze. They just don't seem practically for snowy places since they're not waterproof. (Are these waterproof?)

I would go with the darker brown if I had to pick.

Yodajo

No, they're not waterproof.   I have a waterproof pair for shoveling snow, etc, but they're not anything special.

I also like these and they may be a little more durable/practical.

debs1018

Yodajo:

They have them in black, but my winter coat is brown and I hate mixing black and brown together.

 

I would get the brown then if it matches your coat.

Angela814

Yodajo:

No, they're not waterproof.   I have a waterproof pair for shoveling snow, etc, but they're not anything special.

I also like these and they may be a little more durable/practical.

I do like the bottoms of those better. The others I just imagine getting ruined as soon as you stepped on a salt and snow covered sidewalk.

Yodajo

Angela814:

Yodajo:

No, they're not waterproof.   I have a waterproof pair for shoveling snow, etc, but they're not anything special.

I also like these and they may be a little more durable/practical.

I do like the bottoms of those better. The others I just imagine getting ruined as soon as you stepped on a salt and snow covered sidewalk.

I ordered these.  I just imagined the other ones getting trashed right away.

Thanks for the input!

butterbeansmama

I know I'm replying late and it looks like you already ordered them, but just one thing to think about. The darker the boot the more you will the salt line on them from walking in parking lots, sidewalks, etc. Maybe not something your concerned with, but just thought I'd mention it.