Middle name for Caroline...

mlgd

The name that DH and I most agree on for DD is Caroline. (There are several other names that I like, but that's his favorite on the list.) Anyway, I have several family names as potential middle names that we're considering using, and I was curious to get some opinions:

Caroline Jane (grandmother's first name)

Caroline Louise (my mn, my mother's mn, a great grandmother, DH's grandmother, etc, etc, etc)

Caroline Avery (my sister's name and another old family name going back generations)

Caroline Elizabeth (another one that's all over the family tree)

Our last name starts with a D and is two syllables.  And if you have any other suggestions or think we should start over, chime in too... 

MrsWindyCity

Are you pronouncing it Carol-lin or Carol-line?

I think Jane sounds the best. I tend to like longer first names with shorter MNs and vice versa. 

Julia-Henry

I LOVE Caroline Jane. It's what dd would be called if dh did not get a vote

mrs_tacos

Oh, that's tough- all of them are nice choices. I vote for either Avery or Louise. Elizabeth is pretty, but very common, and I'm not a huge fan of Jane.

07bride

Caroline Louise

mlgd

Julia-Henry:

I LOVE Caroline Jane. It's what dd would be called if dh did not get a vote

Ha. Funnily enough, if MY DH didn't get a vote, right now I'd name her Elizabeth Jane or Elizabeth Louise. 

rose916

Caroline Jane

Annabelle81

I like Caroline Jane. I prefer longer first names and one syllable middle names.

carolinag

MrsWindyCity:

Are you pronouncing it Carol-lin or Carol-line?

i'm assuming caro-line, as that's the proper pronunciation. caro-lin is spelled carolyn. 

personally i like them all except for avery. it just doesn't flow right to me. 

layla1704

Louise

MrsWindyCity

carolinag:

i'm assuming caro-line, as that's the proper pronunciation. caro-lin is spelled carolyn. 

Tell that to the two Carolines I know who both pronounce it -lin

jessawakawaii

I like Caroline Jane.

Manderlin923

Louise for sure!

Don't care for the n's with Caroline Jane and the others don't flow well imo...

FMIL&MOB

Louise, sounds good with Caroline and you get to include both sides of the family.

caro77

I'm Caroline Jayne, so my vote goes for Jane. 

JulieK08

I'm partial to Jane (see siggy), but as I was reading your post, I also thought Caroline Rae would sound pretty...

renafaith

I like Avery best. Elizabeth and Louise both will have too many L's. Jane is just NMS.

amethyst1220

Jane or Elizabeth, but like a pp I thought of Rae too.

berryblndgirl

i like Caroline Louise the best.

Rachelilly23

I like Avery or Jane.