You vote!

brittneycc1982

For my sisters birthday dessert... She doesn't like the typical birthday cake, so I have it narrowed down to these 2. I might have to make both because they look sooo good!

https://annies-eats.com/2009/09/25/smores-cake/

OR

https://www.visionsofsugarplum.com/2009/02/chocolate-cream-pie-with-thin-mint.html

Dani123

OMG!!  Im all about the smores!!!

brightning

Thin Mint! It doesn't look as pretty, but I bet it tastes great.

mrs.aaguilar

The first one!  I just want to go and lick that chocolate, yummy!

Blessed76

i don't think you could go wrong........they both look soooooo good! wish i was invited to her b-day. lol

brittneycc1982

I think I am going with the pie because there are going to be about 15 people there and I will need to make 2... not making 2 cakes.

bridesrighthand

Holy crap, i just gained 10 lbs reading that.

 

S'mores. Hands. Down.

 

I love me some thin mints, but .... S'mores.

Sept17.05Bride

Definitely the s'mores!!  Yummy!

HawaiiBrideGrm

Wow, that's a toughie! Hmm... if you have the thin mints, that sounds delish. However, the smores looks really good, too. Sorry, I'm no help.

momofolivia

mint mint mint