I say it like 'fin-lee', so I'm thinking more Finley... they both look nice to me though. Would you say one different than the other?
I also have seen this as a unisex name... if you've seen it on a girl (I haven't, just on a site is where I see it as unisex) which version was it? I don't wanna (maybe) use the wrong one!
Re: Finlay or Finley?
Me too, I say Fin-lay for Finlay and I think the name is more flattering as Fin-lee, so I'd go with the Finley spelling.
This.