Would you say these go together?

murphyec

I bought an antique dresser a few years ago and have been searching for a matching second dresser since then.  I finally found one on craigslist, but can't decide if it is close enough, or if just the handles match.

 This is like mine

 

This is the one I just found

 

murphyec

Oh I should say that they are not the same maker.  The above one is Duncan Phyfe and the bottom one is Beacon Hill.

Nikki1007

They look pretty close. The bottom trim is different and the top one is curved and the bottom one is not. I wouldn't sit them next to each other, but on different sides of the room they would be fine.

babydontforget

They don't match, but they coordinate, and that's fine. Unless you plan to hunt for the exact manufacturer, exact stain, exact hardware, what I imagine you're looking for is another piece of the same vintage. And this definitely seems to fit the bill.?

Serendipitie

Close enough for government work!

yogisunam

I think it totally works. If in person they aren't as close you can just make sure that something else in your room in an exact match...ie, curtains and beadpread cover...which will tie the overall room together.

Maybe. I really don't have any idea.

smilelari

It's always hard to tell from pictures but I suspect they'll look great together

Serendipitie

I happen to love slightly mismatched things, so i think it's awesome!

mmariluh

Nikki1007:

They look pretty close. The bottom trim is different and the top one is curved and the bottom one is not. I wouldn't sit them next to each other, but on different sides of the room they would be fine.

Ditto!