Girl name help: riding that Southern / British / Jane Austen vibe + "settling" for a name?

fern_and_feather

Hello mamas, we have an Emma Jane and a Caroline and are looking for a potential girl's name to join the team. I have loved hearing the sweet old ladies at the farmers market say "Oh what sweet Southern names" or "How British and darling," and I really do love the classic, not-that-trendy, great for women and for little girls standard we've set.

I *love* the name Charlotte, but that's off the table due to family reasons. I also really like Josephine, Genevieve, and Marion or Marianne, and maaaaybe Margaret. Elinor is also near the top for us, I think.

Similar names that are not on our list: Elizabeth, Victoria, Julia, Violet, Mary.

Can you think of any other ideas? We're having a hard time finding something we both love. (Secondary question - have you ever had to "settle" for a name? Like, you pick the first name and your partner picks the middle? Or you both softly agree on a name that you both like enough but don't love?)

mb0112

I like your options especially Josephine and Genevieve. Margaret fits really well with the sisters but I just don't love it. Adding

Lydia 
Vera
Natalie 
Jacqueline 
Vivienne 
Alice
Bridget 
Annabelle 
Lucy

meggyme

Samantha
Jocelyn
Adriana/Adrianne
Helen

cmill828

Magnolia
Daphne 
Sarah
Eloise 
Jane
Darcy
Emma
Virginia
Hannah
Blythe
Georgia/Georgianna
Antoinette