Wrenley vs Charlotte

knottie34154e632dc9ea0c

I feel like I'm driving myself nuts thinking about names for our baby girl. I really like the name wrenley but my husband likes the name Charlotte. I dont dislike Charlotte, but i just cant seem to drop Wrenley. When I tell people the two options for her name, some cringe at the name Wrenley but I just love it. We do have a son with a W name but im not trying to match those on purpose. Infact I do worry that if we have a third child, then I'd have to pick a W name because the other two have it. I'm sure I'm overthinking it.

Her middle name will for sure be Kay (a passed down name in the family) so it will either be Wrenley Kay or Charlotte Kay.
Im wondering what you think and if we will ever come to a conclusion on which name would be better.

boschbaby23

funny you posted those name my mothers name is Charlotte Kay...it's very classic and timeless so I guess I'm a bit partial though lol

harpseal135

Sorry, the only choice is Charlotte. 

meggyme

Charlotte. Or just Wren, but Wren Kay sounds a little odd. 

Adding Raven, Robin, Tenley, Paisley, Haley, Hadley, Riley.

Wishilivedinflorida

Wrenley sounds made up and babyish to me. Charlotte is way better and pairs better with Kay. 

For what it’s worth my first two have the same first initial and this third baby will not. It was incidental and I think that’s really reading into things. They will spend most of their lives not as a sibling set but as individuals. Nobody will care if their names match or not. 

knottie_knottie1

I also like Charlotte better than Wrenley and agree with one of the PP that Wren is nice too.

Charlotte also has some good nn like Cece, Char, Lottie, and Charlie

mb0112

No contest, Charlotte is a much nicer name. Classic and pretty with options for nicknames.
I'm one of those people who would cringe at Wrenly. 

kbmt

I prefer Charlotte too.

Knottie1433187098

Wrenley sounds made up. Kind of cringey. Wren on its own would work! 

ravenhairedgirl83

Charlotte by a mile. I almost hate to say this because it's such a personal choice thing, but names that sound super trendy or made up are really cringe to me. 

fvera88

Charlotte, hands down.

annettyy

I like Charlotte more.