Which name do you prefer?

ILRN

Arthur nn Archie
Oscar nn Ozzy

For reference siblings are
Jackson nn Jack
Lucille nn Lucy
Benjamin nn Benny/Benji 

paytonpedro

You have great names. Personally I’m leaving towards Oscar, but you can’t go wrong with either choice. 

meggyme

I prefer Arthur, nn Archie or Art. Ozzie immediately makes me think Osbourne or the Grouch, but maybe that’s just me.

m2a

Both names are great but I do like Oscar a little more. 😀

knottie07ae027a08ab2176

Arthur is my vote! Seems much more distinguished 🤗

mommarosie1

Arthur is so cute! Oscar reminds me of the angry character off Sesame Street. Archie is a great nickname.

knottie7cf

Archie!!! Keep the -ie / -y sound w the other siblings 

karbaud

I prefer Oscar over Arthur. But, I love Archie as a stand-alone name. I also love Archer. It’s in my top 3, but doesn’t go well with my surname.

Knottie1433187098

While technically Archie is a nickname for Arthur, it seems pretty unrelated to the full name and as a teacher I’d be like… what?! Ozzy is a little less of a stretch so I’d go with that. 

lea-v3

I'm not an Arthur or Archie fan. I'd definitely vote Oscar/Ozzy. It's feels less trendy to me too.

lillibettt

I like Arthur more, but Oscar is a lovely name too.