I love Jacob but I feel too like a lot of people use Jake now instead of the full formal name. I prefer Jacob as a whole with nickname Jake. I feel like Caleb is a good choice if you like Jacob but not the popularity. But I agree with everyone here. Can't really go wrong with any of these names!
I voted for Peter. I find it so refreshing. Benjamin and Jacob are nice, but overused IMO. My son has 3 Jacobs in his 3rd grade class! They all differentiate with their last initial.
Re: Help me decide - boy's name!
And Peter all the way!
TTC since September 2012