I've been doing it all: the supplements, the pumping, oatmeal, tons of water, milkmaid tea, everything. No real increase in supply. I've been pumping more often but don't pump very long, just long enough to get the milk out and then I'm done. Should I be pumping way longer - like keep pumping after the milk has stopped - to signal to my body the baby needs more milk? Or does that not really do anything to pump for longer periods of time? I only thought I needed to pump more often but that doesn't seem to be increasing my supply. How often should I really be pumping in a 24 hour period?
Re: So when you're trying to increase supply...
LO is 11 months today and I'm currently nursing him twice a day, morning and before bed, and pumping once at work (I make the same amount pumping once vs pumping twice). LO gets two bottles a day, one of formula and one of pumped milk (or 1/2 pumped milk and 1/2 formula if I didn't make enough that day). We're weaning at 12 months, so I plan to drop the final pumping session in a few weeks and will give LO two bottles of formula a day until he's 12 months, then at 12 months will drop either the evening or morning nursing session, and then the other session a week later.
I have mixed feelings about weaning. I hate the pump, so I'm not sad about that, but I don't mind nursing at all in the mornings or at night and LO loves it, so that makes it harder. But I know it's time and I want to give myself a break before we start trying for baby #2 in December. I still can't believe baby is almost a year!
This may not have answered your question, but I found that even if I added or increased pumping sessions, it didn't make a difference for me. My body has stopped responding to the pump - LO is able to get so much more milk out than my pump. And the hormone thing doesn't help!
Hope you can find something that works! And if you do need to supplement with formula, it's ok! I was so determined not to use formula from the start and did everything I could to avoid it, but in the end, that was my only option, and honestly, it's ok! Baby is happy, I'm happy, and there have been no issues!