Girl names - thoughts?

Moxie Lady

DH and I have narrowed it down to three names (middle names TBD).  DD is Natalie Elise (nn Nat).  What do you think?

Shoshana (we are Jewish - nn Shosh)
Evangeline (nn Evie)
Ophelia (nn could be Fie or Lia)

TIA!

Bringmemylongswordho

Shoshana 

karlimonster

Shoshana times infinity.

kmvisioli

Evangeline or Shoshana. I don't love the nn Shosh, which gives Evie the edge for me.

SmrBrd2012

I'm tired of evangeline/eve/evie. The other two are great.

Sematti

Love shoshana 

dreamcatch-her

Evangeline 100% !! 

sid464

Evangeline/Evie.

I'm biased from this experience, but I've only known one Shoshana, but she was not a pleasant person! I don't have a great association with that name.

KyleeWaller

Shoshana by a wide margin. Ophelia as a runner-up.

ashleyandely

Well, Ophelia is my DDs name so I obviously love it. But I'm not much help since my bff is Evangeline (goes by Evan though) and I love Shoshana. 

jessjuhnke

Ophelia

KaLikeAWind

KyleeWaller said:

Shoshana by a wide margin. Ophelia as a runner-up.

+1

nanner26

Shoshana

JadaBlue

Shoshana-I love Ophelia but can't get past the Shakespeare/suicide association.

CaboBride2015

Shoshana or Evangeline!

RoseShadow873

Ophelia

stubbychuck

I love Ophelia with the nickname Fi!

onebadmotha

I actually love all three, which is rare. I would vote for Shoshana, because it's less common and has ties to your Jewish heritage. 

Edited- because spelling

beachylex

Evangeline is beautiful

magsugar13

Ophelia!!

WildWhat

I love Ophelia, but not sure I could bring myself to use it with the strong suicide association. Shoshana is beautiful, and I agree with others that "Evie" names are getting overdone. 

Eko14

I like Evie on it's own but am over Evangeline/Evelyn.
Never heard Shoshana but don't like it at all.
Ophelia is so flakey and will never shake suicide/Hamlet reference.
I love Natalie. Nat makes me think of head lice though.

gonetothesea

They're all great, but I love Ophelia. Ophelia Evangeline?

alyssa0714

Evangeline is the only one on your list that I like. Evie is such a cute nickname too!