Help us find some middle ground!

AmberLiz99

dh and I cannot reconcile our taste in girls names. He likes super trendy, and I like more vintage or traditional. 

His current favorites:
Harper
Sadie
Ellie

my current favorites:
Kate
Scarlet 
Anna
Natalie

anyone have suggestions for names that might fall somewhere in the middle? Or classic names with trendy nn that dh might like? 

If if I read one more list baby names online I'm going to go crazy! Haha 

AndiPandi127

I actually think you two are closer than you think - do you like Eleanor nn Ellie? Other suggestions that are classic-ish that can have trendy nns:

Rosalie
Lorelei
Emeline
Estella

ellebee2

Stella
Charlotte
Audrey
Alison (nn Ali)
Lillian (nn Lily)
Sophie
Isabel (nn Izzy)
Cora

PinkLady2015

another vote for Eleanor nn Ellie or

Eloise nn Ellie

Evelyn nn Eve or Evie

Camille/Camilla nn Cammie

Rosalind nn Roz

Evangeline nn Evie

Natalia nn Talia or Nat

Latina211508

I like Natalie the best. 
Elise 
Iris 
Camille(a) 
Joslyn
Josephine(a) 
Evelyn