New thoughts for girl names. Feedback please

KateLouise · April 2015

Our girls are Elizabeth Grace and Jane Hermione.

Previously top of my list has been Lydia Magdalene, Marigold Therese and Clara Therese.

Recently I've been thinking about:

Athena

Evelyn

Flora

Jemima

Stella

Any thoughts?

Thanks ladies

Sassenach1743 · April 2015

I like Lydia Marigold!

Jemima is a total guilty pleasure name for me, I love it. But my hubby thinks it's terrible. All he thinks of is Aunt Jemima Pancake Syrup.

Stella, Clara, and Evelyn are nice choices but so popular lately. Flora is okay. Athena doesn't really fit well with your current sib set.

Magdalene and Therese are not my style.

wassuphoes · April 2015

I like Lydia.

unfortunately, Jemima makes me think of the syrup as well.

LizWhiz87 · April 2015

I like Stella a lot. Jemima is cute, but may be too 'out there.' The others are not my style. Lydia Magdalene is gorgeous!

LoveIsOwlYouNeed · April 2015

I really like Lydia with Elizabeth and Jane. It's a good sib set.

finchfeeder80 · April 2015

Evelyn is one of my top picks, as well.

Kate0034 · April 2015

brita722 said:
Jemima is a total guilty pleasure name for me, I love it. But my hubby thinks it's terrible. All he thinks of is Aunt Jemima Pancake Syrup.

Sorry but I agree with the husband. I just couldn't meet a person named Jemima without laughing..

Either Evelyn or Clara would be lovely with sibset, but as PP stated they're getting so popular.

I second the votes for Lydia. It's pretty and less common. Elizabeth, Jane, and Lydia... Very Jane Austen!!

benmel31 · April 2015

I really like Lydia from your original list. I prefer it with Lydia Therese. I think Lydia is beautiful and not super common but not way out there. If our LO is a girl, she will likely be named Lydia.

Of your new list, I am biased to Evelyn. However, I prefer avoiding alliteration in names. Therefore, I would not choose Evelyn to go with Elizabeth and Jane.

I agree that Elizabeth, Jane, and Lydia make a great sibset!

MamaWren919 · April 2015

I like Clara and Evelyn best, especially with your daughters. Your girls names are so classic a name like Marigold, Lydia, or Athena just doesn't go to me.