Jane as a sister to Anne?

e1223

My husband and I are having a disagreement about this - I'm pregnant with #3, #1 is Anne (we call her Annie), #2 is Luke (which is not relevant to this particular discussion but whatever) - my husband's favorite girl name is Jane - now I love the name Jane, a lot, but to me it's VERY similar to Anne, especially if we ended up calling her Janie, which I know we will - we call Luke Lukey all the time, it just happens. I know one has a short A one has a long A, but still. My girl name choice, which he also "likes, but not as much as Jane" is Charlotte, and if we do that it'll be Charlotte Jane, and our boy name is Charles.

Anyway, do people think Anne and Jane are too similar to each other to use for sisters?

Sassenach1743

Not at all. Anne and Jane are lovely together and not too similar. 

wassuphoes

I don't think they are too similar.

MamaWren919

I knew twins named Anne and Jane and never thought it was weird. I love Charlotte Jane too though!

nicosh8

I think they pair together nicely

e1223

Thanks for the feedback! I will not show these to my husband, ha Guess we'll just see 1 - if it's a girl, and 2 - which feels right once she's born

HeavenBlessedMom

I like it much better than Charlotte
Love charles!

4N6s

I don't think they're similar at all.
I like Jane so much more than Charlotte.

saham07

I think that they are fine together. Charlotte is nice too.

g8trkim

I don't find them similar at all other than being one syllable. I think they go really well together without sounding the same. Anne, Luke, and Jane are a great sibset.

LNic5

I actually know a sibset of girls named Anne and Jane

holli0801

My best friend is Jayne, her sister is Anne. Always thought they complimented one another!