CPT: Who Wants to Play Personal Shopper?! Updated with PIP.

gutsymama

My boots are falling apart and I have a gift card for DSW. I want something versatile & neutral that I can wear with jeans or skirts. I am looking at these three:

[Pictures in comment below]

ashie624

All 3 links go to the main page..no picture

atlvol

I can't see them either  

[Deleted User]

I can see the second option but that's all. 

gutsymama

Well shoot. 

Let me try again.

gutsymama

#1     

#2 

#3 

[Deleted User]

I like them all but I think I like option 2 the best so that's what I chose. I don't think you can go wrong with any of them

sparkymcgeee

They are all really cute but I like #3. I think what we're saying here is you shouldn't ask us because we are obviously not helpful.

grapeskittles4lyfe

I prefer #2. What you would need to consider with #1 is that you will see a LOT more wear on the folds. So if the boots aren't leather and/or you're planning on using them for ever, I'd be leery of folds.

(Or maybe I'm the only fold-ruiner around. YRMV)

atlvol

I like #2, but I'm with @byjove03, I wish it was brown, like #3.  

ashie624

I like #1 but @amparo1981‌ has a good point..so I chose #3. 2nd best imo

jemasa33

I like #1 the best, but I NEVER wear heels. I would pick #2 for myself. 

[Deleted User]

Does #2 come in another color? I would choose two but I think brown is more versatile, so maybe three.

I don't like option one as much. I think for everyday boots, a classic and plain look is best.

[Deleted User]

Also - and I am not calling you old and actually don't know how old you are but I'm guessing ~30 like most of us - I think the first ones look quite "young" and I would imagine them on someone ~20.

Stacey099

It's so close!

EagleWife

I vote 3. Most versatile and classic looking, I think. What did you choose, @gutsymama?

ilovemyducks21

jemasa33 said:

I like #1 the best, but I NEVER wear heels. I would pick #2 for myself. 

This exactly. I would buy #1 then hate it because of the heels.

Dani428

I Love love love #3 - great color, classy but stylish, and they look super comfy. Second choice is #2.

gutsymama

@EagleWife I still haven't ordered....I can't decide Maybe I will order all three and try them on and then take 2 of them back? 

@PickleX I will be 30 in 2 months. Maybe those boots are my early-mid-life crisis? It doesn't come in brown, just that color (it looks grey to me, but they call it taupe) and black. I have never worn black boots. 

@iandloveandyou1 @jemasa33 @Ilovemyducks21 I can walk all day in decent wedges, so that's not an issue. I actually prefer a little wedge to make my legs look longer & thinner.

@biggunsbo you said SHAFT teeheeheeheehee 

EagleWife

@gutsymama, I totally pictured you bumping in the aisles of a DSW with different boots on each foot, refreshing for responses.

Stina2012

#3 fo shizzle!