Second half of twin set

lupineaura

Hi everyone,

I've posted my favorite names here before, and your help has been fabulous! We found out recently the twins are both girls.

I think I've finally talked my husband out of alliterative names.

We are pretty sure one twin will be Talia, likely with the mn Sage.

The current front runner for the second twin is Alice, but I've recently been drawn to Anna. I might actually like it more than Alice, and I think the nickname Annie is cute for a little girl.

I'm worried Talia and Anna are too similar/almost rhyme-y. Thoughts? 

Big sister is Zoe Paige.

I admit a bonus to Alice is that all three girls will have names that end in different sounds. "Annie" and "Zoe" rhyme, but doesn't seem TOO offensive.

conradraging

I prefer Alice to Anna, and agree that Anna and Talia are a little close for my taste.

hillgirl322

Alice all the way! Personally I don't like the idea of both names ending in a.

Helenahhandbasket

They aren't sing songy to me.

magsugar13

I'll be odd man out...i hate alice it is so old ladyish.

anna is much better imo

Seahorse85

Alice gets my vote. Love it!

Renisra+2

I think I like the name Anna slightly more than I like Alice, but with Talia, I would prefer Alice.

lupineaura

Thank you all for your opinions!

TKO86

I really like Anna however very much agree with @ugotstarbucked‌ that Frozen will catapult the name up on the popularity charts. So long as you are okay with this, my vote goes to Anna.

blu-eyedwife

I love the name Alice, but I personally don't like it with Talia.  To me, they sound similar, and have a lot of the same letters - not an exact anagram but close enough that I wouldn't use them with twins.

Have you thought about Anne?  You get the feel of both Alice and Anna, different endings, no sing-songyness.

jburdet1

I'm not a huge of Talia.
I actually prefer Alice and Anna as twin set.
However, between the two I would choose Alice with Talia. I like how they look together sharing the "Ali" letter combination.

4N6s

I like Alice more than Anna and Thalia more than Talia.

DawnJM25

Talia and Anna are too similar and awkward to say together.  Alice and Talia are nice together.

lupineaura

Thank you all! You made some good points. As much as I like Anna, I like Talia more. I think I am leaning towards Alice. It might change! My husband likes Ashley but I'm on the fence. Naming two kids at once is hard!

prettypea08

lupineaura said:

Thank you all! You made some good points. As much as I like Anna, I like Talia more. I think I am leaning towards Alice. It might change! My husband likes Ashley but I'm on the fence. Naming two kids at once is hard!

Yeah, I don't envy you. Go with Alice, I think it is best with Talia.

juliad2010

Talia and Alice both share ALI and it's too similar IMO. Not terrible, just not my preference.