fisher price cradle and swing vs. mamaroo?

kstirton

We bought a used mamaroo and while lo will tolerate it I'm thinking she may like the snuggly fit and swing better with the cradle and swing from fisher price. Anyone have experience with both or prefer one to the other? I'm a little reluctant to get rid of the mamaroo bc she will sleep in it ... but thinking a swing may be a better fit

Richardsmom_817

My first 3 kids loved their FP papasan swing....I only just got the mamaroo w/ this baby because we will try anything as he does not sleep during the day.....it's not really helping like we had thought, but I am going to hang onto it for a bit...see if maybe he will like it more as the weeks go on.