February 2013 Moms

s/o Curious about unschooling? Come in.

wifeofadamwifeofadam member
edited October 2014 in February 2013 Moms
I was thinking about you ladies all morning as we did our "school lessons".  I think this is a good example to show how you can take a boring chore, like landscaping, and turn it into "school" for your kids.  Last night I picked up another bulk food order from Azure and I had to make room in my pantry for it.  When I opened the door to the pantry stuff was falling all over the place.  I told the kids I was going to organize it while they played and they all said they wanted to help.  Time for school, I guess.  This worked in my favor because my oldest is a Type A like his father, to the point where all the labels have to face the same way, so I knew he'd do a better job than I would ;)

So we emptied out the entire pantry.  I had my 7YO help the girls sort stuff by category, so that was a good matching exercise for the little ones (also worked on colors) - put the red beets with the other red beets or put the green spinach with the other spinach, etc.  The boys quizzed my 3YO on fruits and veggies - is a beet a fruit or veggie?  What about a peach?  A cashew is a nut - did you know a coconut is also a tree nut?  Stuff like that.

Once we had it all cleaned out and wiped down, we started to fill it back up.  DS1 made an inventory sheet for us.  He listed each item as we put it back into the pantry (later we fixed any misspelled words on his list - his spelling lesson for the day).  We had columns for quarts, pints, half-pints, and other misc. measurements.  We did some multiplication as we filled the pantry - our shelves fit three quarts deep, so once he saw how many jars he had on the shelf he would multiply by three to get the total.

While filling the pantry we talked about how many pints go in a quart, how many quarts in a gallon, etc.  If we had some dried goods that were low in say a quart jar he would guess if it was less than half full and then we would test to see if the contents would fit in a pint jar.

When we were done we took his inventory sheet and calculated how many total quarts of canned veggies and fruits we put up this year - so he took all of the half-pints and divided by four, he took his pints and divided by two, and then added it all to the number of quarts.  We reinforced some of the fraction lessons that are currently on his Saxon curriculum here, too. 

On top of all of that, we found one jar of my tomato sauce that apparently didn't seal and had spoiled.  The kids investigated the mold on top and asked questions about it.  That led to a little lesson on where penicillin comes from and how canning kills the bacteria and makes it impossible to grow.  Then they scraped off some mold to look at under their microscope.

image

On top of all of the math, spelling, and science, I feel like the kids learned a lot about patience (working with their little siblings), team work, and determination (they wanted to stop halfway through, but we finished the task).  Oh, and now Mama has an organized pantry, so I say it's a win-win.

That's how unschooling works for us.  We'll still do a math worksheet later on and read a few chapters from our literature selection, but the rest of the day will be arts/crafts, free play, and some board games.

AW - BTW, It was 183 quarts (after we also counted what's in the freezer).  I still have to finish squash and pumpkin, but I'm thinking that's about it for the year.

image
    

Re: s/o Curious about unschooling? Come in.

  • Loading the player...
  • I love this! I was homeschooled and we did have a curriculum we used but I think a huge part of schooling is using day to day things to learn!


    I have a Daughter born 2/26/2013. She is pretty much amazing!


    Lilypie Pregnancy tickers

  • Sagen said:
    That is awesome! Do you check in with the public school to see if you are somewhat in line with things they are learning? Just out of curiosity how you run things. Having a friend who home schooled who decided not to, and now her child is held back and way behind, I think following a guideline would be beneficial KWIM? Going a head of course if you can but making sure they meet the minium for their grade. It sounds like you are going above and beyond of course, but I do wonder in the homeschool community if making sure they can meet grade level criteria is important, or not. 
    It varies by state, obviously.  In Ohio we have a few options for homeschooling.  Most homeschoolers have to notify with the state each year of their intent to homeschool and with the notification you provide a list of curricula/resources.  When you submit your notification you also have to submit an assessment from the previous year.  Your assessment has to be signed off on by a licensed teacher (which is kind of ridiculous IMO, because any teacher works.  So a Kindergarten teacher could sign off on your 10th grader's work).  The assessment consists of a portfolio of their work - some teachers will require an interview with the kids and some don't.  In every homeschooling community there are teachers who are homeschool-friendly and work with the community, and there are even some teachers who are homeschoolers and are willing to sign off on the work.  The other option is to submit standardized test scores.  Your child simply has to score in the 25th percentile or above. 

    The other option in Ohio for homeschoolers is to create your own non-chartered, non-tax school.  This is what a lot of people with deeply-held religious beliefs do.  If you create your own school, you do not have to provide assessments and basically, the government has no involvement in your kids' educations.  In order to create your own school, someone in your home has to have a Bachelor's degree and if you have more than six students, you are subject to fire and safety inspections.

    Knowing that I'm a religious Libertarian, you can probably imagine which group we're in.

    So, to answer your question, I personally am not required to check in with anyone and that is completely legal in my state.  I submit paperwork once a year to the Ohio DOE and to my local school board treasurer to let them know where my kids are, but that's it.

    I am not really worried about following grade levels.  My kids don't even know what grade they are supposed to be in.  I think it's silly to define them by the norm for their age.  They are individuals with their own strengths and weaknesses.  We do follow a math curriculum that aligns with the Common Core, but neither of my boys are in "their grade" - one is two years ahead and the other is one year ahead. 

    I do assess my kids throughout the year.  In the spring I will do reading assessments with them.  Everything you need to do one is available for free online.  That's how I can tell what grade level they are reading at.  They are both ahead for their age, but even if they weren't, I wouldn't worry yet.  As we know with toddlers and babies, there is a wide range of "normal" for developmental milestones.  Reading is no different.  Eventually they will catch up - research actually shows that early reading really doesn't provide a benefit past fourth grade, the age in which later readers usually begin to perform at the same level as the early readers.

    Apart from reading and math, I'm not sure I need to be on track with any guidelines and criteria.  Eventually, as they get older, if they want to go to college, there will be certain coursework they will have to complete in order to pass SATs or have a valid high school transcript.  If they choose that route, I'm confident that they will be motivated learners and will easily learn what they need to when the time comes.  Our kids will most likely enter college at the age of 16 and hopefully earn as Associate's degree by age 18, if their desire is to go to college.  That's not uncommon for most of the homeschooling families I know.
        
  • Thanks for the post @wifeofadam , it was really interesting. I'm not very familiar with homeschooling, but I don't really like that curriculum that is now coming along with common core, so I am leaning towards finding a charter school for our kids. If I didn't have to work full time, I might consider homeschooling.
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker 

    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • Can I have your pantry? ;) I want to learn how to can!
                    We're Going to be a Family of 5!

    Lilypie - (PaHE) Lilypie - (4noI)

                                   Lilypie - (2q9u)


  • djm31012djm31012 member
    edited October 2014

    I think these are great lessons and very interesting. You are probably way smarter than I am...I am not sure I could answer all the science questions your kids ask :)  Maybe a dumb question, but without following a sort of curriculum, how do you know your kids are "ahead?" Not being snarky..genuinely asking.

  • Sagen said:
    Why do you think it is silly to make sure they are on track? You're ahead, but maybe not everyone would be. I think it is important to make sure a child doesn't far too far behind don't you think? The school system does that, so as a private home teacher to your own children, it seems like a no brainer that parents would need to have some checks as well. Not everyone is going to be on top of things as you are. 
    Oh, I agree that I think it's appropriate for parents to make sure their kids are on track.  I just think the current system is silly.  It's really not tracking anything, as there are so many ways to get around it.  And I don't see how a licensed teacher of younger grades somehow has a magical power to tell me that my high schooler is on track any more than I can. 

    It's just unfortunate, as with anything, that in order to protect certain individuals you have to trample on the rights of responsible people.  That's how it works with everything, I guess.
        
  • @wifeofadam, I taught a similar lesson to my biology undergrads a few weeks ago. We identified fruits versus veggies, eudicots versus monocots, looked at seed and fruit anatomy, and figured out what parts of the plant their favorite vegetables included. It was so much fun :) Honestly, I've spent a lot of time teaching science to both elementary-aged kids and college students and the best lessons work for both age groups, just varying in the degree of detail they expect students to learn.
    Thank you so much for recognizing that!  So many people criticize and say there is no way that you can educate so many kids at varying levels and do it well.  They don't realize that the bext lessons involve all of the kids.  Just like you said - you just go a little more in depth for the older kids while the little ones color pictures or practice spelling words about the topic, but the main concept is shared with everyone and everyone benefits from it!
        
  • djm31012 said:

    I think these are great lessons and very interesting. You are probably way smarter than I am...I am not sure I could answer all the science questions your kids ask :)  Maybe a dumb question, but without following a sort of curriculum, how do you know your kids are "ahead?" Not being snarky..genuinely asking.

    Like I mentioned above, one way to tell would be to look at what concepts they are learning and compare that to what grade level it is being taught in school.  For us in math, we use curriculum, so we can gauge what level they are at that way.  If we weren't using the curricula, there are a variety of free online assessments they could complete to evaluate their grade level.

    For reading, you can also do free online reading assessments.

    I know my kids are ahead because the last assessments we did (last spring), my then 6YO was reading at a 4.5 level - halfway through a fourth grade year.  He's also two years ahead in his math curriculum. 

    But there are other ways I could gauge is I wanted to - I know what knowledge he knows in terms of geography, history or science.  I could look at my state DOE website, which lists all of the learning goals by grade, and know in which grades those concepts and topics are being introduced.   But to be honest, that sounds like a lot of work, and I'm pretty confident we're doing just fine.  If I ever really wanted to know, I have my ways.  And any child can take standardized tests, even if just for fun, at any time.
        
  • Won't there come a time when you can't teach them something? My parents are very smart but there's no way they could have taught me AP Physics and Chemistry, Shakespeare, Greek, and many other subjects I was exposed to in high school. There has to be a limit to unschooling, right?

    I agree with there being a developmental limit for unschooling. At some point in middle school, most kids reach a point where they learn really well from books. I remember hiting this point around 5th grade. I remember spending more time with my text books and working ahead. I actually finished all of my 5th grade work in about 4 months.

    Now, my mom didn't really take an unschooling approach, and we always had some text curricula, but I've observed this same developmental shift in other students and homeschoolers.

    However, @Sterling13‌, there are hundreds of resources and different subject curriculums available to homeschoolers to teach any subject matter you can think of. I'm actually eager for my daughter to get interested in some of these more advanced subjects. Math is boring. ;). Shakespeare and Chaucer and Boccacio are fascinating. (And my dad can read and speak Greek.)

    That isn't too say, my husband and I won't continually revisit our decision to homeschool every year. We will always do what is best for the kids, whether that be homeschooling, private school, or public school.
                    We're Going to be a Family of 5!

    Lilypie - (PaHE) Lilypie - (4noI)

                                   Lilypie - (2q9u)


  • Won't there come a time when you can't teach them something? My parents are very smart but there's no way they could have taught me AP Physics and Chemistry, Shakespeare, Greek, and many other subjects I was exposed to in high school. There has to be a limit to unschooling, right?
    Like others have mentioned, I'm not sure what I do is 100% unschooling.  Unschoolers, at least "radical" ones, wouldn't claim me.

    I feel confident teaching my kids just about any subject.  I learn along with them and that's the best part of it all. 

    Not every student takes AP Physics, but if I have a child that is very interested in science or is interested in attending a university that requires those kinds of courses, I have many options.  If I don't feel confident in teaching the course I can purchase a curriculum, many of which are computer-based, and very user-friendly.  I could also enroll my child in college courses (for free - bonus) to gain that knowledge.  I can supplement in any way - hiring tutors if necessary, too.  Teaching Physics, however, doesn't scare me at all.  The teacher guides that come with curricula are very thorough.

    But really, I'm laying the foundation now by creating very independent learners and critical thinkers.  My goal during these younger years is to create a love of learning, particularly reading, so that my kids will one day be able to teach themselves anything.  If they want to learn about Shakespeare, they don't need me to do it (although I would probably enjoy learning along with them, so I'm sure I'd be involved).  My job will be to facilitate things so that they have all of the necessary resources to teach themselves anything they want.  A passion for Shakespeare?  It's my job to seek out workshops, online resources, books, college professors, documentaries, or anything else and provide those things for my children so they can learn as much about it as they possibly can.  And to me, that's another benefit to this kind of education.  If they truly have a passion, they can devote their energy to learning as much about it as they want, instead of having to divide their time with subjects they aren't interested in at all and won't likely use as adults.

    I really don't think there is a limit to what is possible as long as you're invested and have the ability to provide the resources your kids need to learn.
        

  • I would be very interested in homeschooling, but DH and I both work and enjoy our careers, so I do not thing that we would have time to do justice to our kiddos' education by ourselves. I do feel lucky that we have strong backgrounds in STEM fields, english, and history, so we will be able to enrich our childrens' educations. It is so true that almost all household activities can include a strong learning component - it's all about the presentation!
    I forgot to add - you're a faculty member, aren't you?  I have a colleague that is a faculty member and homeschools.  She's also a single mom.  Her son is very smart!  Somehow she makes it work.  :)
        
  • djm31012 said:

    I am not sure I could answer all the science questions your kids ask :) 

    I forgot to address this part.  I don't have all of the answers either.  We have a journal we keep in our house and if the kids ever ask a question I can't answer, we add it to the list.  The next week when we go to the library, we check out books on the topic and all read them together to learn the answers.  Or if it's a quick yes or no answer or something like that, we will get on the computer and Google it together.

    You don't need to have all of the answers.  In fact, I think that not having them sometimes teaches valuable lessons to your kids - that no one knows everything.  And it also shows them how to seek out knowledge for themselves whenever they are curious.  They take ownership in finding the answers instead of simply being lectured to by someone.
        
  • singingseasingingsea member
    edited October 2014
    wifeofadam I think your project with the kids was really cool :)

    Even though Kieran will be going to public school I think there are so many ways we can teach our children outside of school. I plan on being heavily involved in his education.

    You being from Ohio...have you took your kids to COSI yet? I want to take Kieran but I think he's still too young.

    Edit: Sometimes I feel like public school/my parents failed me. I was diagnosed with ADHD and learning disabilities and received zero help and struggled all through school. If my son turns out to have these same issues I'm probably going to be a crazy ma ma bear and make sure he gets the help he needs.
    Married: August 2008
    DS born: February 2013
    TTC #2: Nov. 14
    Chemical pregnancy 09/16/15
    BFP: 12/25/15 EDD: 09/04/16
  • You being from Ohio...have you took your kids to COSI yet? I want to take Kieran but I think he's still too young.
    We did COSI when my oldest was about the age of our toddlers.  He loved it.  They get something out of it no matter what age they are!! 

    I haven't taken them back yet.  We've done Boonshoft in Dayton and the Imagination Station in Toledo (we actually bought a membership there a few years ago).  Thanks for reminding me that we need to fit COSI in this year!

    If you do go, buy an annual membership.  If you buy it for one science museum in Ohio you can get discounted admission at the rest of them around the state.  Same for zoos!
        

  • If you do go, buy an annual membership.  If you buy it for one science museum in Ohio you can get discounted admission at the rest of them around the state.  Same for zoos!

    Awesome. Will do :D
    Married: August 2008
    DS born: February 2013
    TTC #2: Nov. 14
    Chemical pregnancy 09/16/15
    BFP: 12/25/15 EDD: 09/04/16
  • wifeofadamwifeofadam member
    edited October 2014
    @wifeofadam, I taught a similar lesson to my biology undergrads a few weeks ago. We identified fruits versus veggies, eudicots versus monocots, looked at seed and fruit anatomy, and figured out what parts of the plant their favorite vegetables included. It was so much fun :)
    Oh, and you'll probably get a chuckle out of this - my kids have been known to correct people when they incorrectly call certain fruits veggies.  They'll be like, "Um, that cucumber or epper or okra or whatever has seeds and flowers.  It's actually a fruit."  I have THOSE kids ;)
        
  • lrtrauth said:
    I'm just putting this out there,... I don't believe that a coconut is a tree nut; its a fruit. The FDA lumps it into the tree nut category, but not all individuals with tree nut allergies are allergic to coconut.
    Touche.  Although, as a food allergy family, we consider coconut a tree nut, as does our allergist and family doc.  We also have friends with tree nut allergies that react to coconut (and not just when ingested - even when in cosmetic products), so I guess that's where we're coming from.

    But thanks for correcting me.  I'll be sure to remember to pass the info along to the kids ;)
        
  • wifeofadamwifeofadam member
    edited October 2014
    DC2London said:
    lrtrauth said:
    I'm just putting this out there,... I don't believe that a coconut is a tree nut; its a fruit. The FDA lumps it into the tree nut category, but not all individuals with tree nut allergies are allergic to coconut.
    Touche.  Although, as a food allergy family, we consider coconut a tree nut, as does our allergist and family doc.  We also have friends with tree nut allergies that react to coconut (and not just when ingested - even when in cosmetic products), so I guess that's where we're coming from.

    But thanks for correcting me.  I'll be sure to remember to pass the info along to the kids ;)
    Interesting.  Our allergists do not (either of them, Jack's or Rhys') treat coconut as a tree nut.  They consider it a stone fruit.  Further proof that the world of food allergies is fraught with disagreement :/  Not that that makes it difficult for those of us trying to keep our kids healthy.  Nope, not at all ;)
    Seriously.  I remember when my son was originally diagnosed with his peanut allergy.  Our allergist also wanted us to avoid tree nuts, simply because the risk of cross-contamination among different nuts was so high.  I remember the literature on the tree nuts including coconuts (although we never avoided them at that time, as coconut oil was and still is our main milk substitute). 

    I think we've discussed how our allergist experiences have differed on here before.  It's really amazing how treatments and info vary depending on who you talk to.  Even among the different allergists we have seen, we get different answers depending on who we talk to. 

    But I guess that's the case with any different type of medical professional.  I mean, think of all of the conflicting advice given to all of the women on this board during our pregnancies by our different OBs and MWs. 

    As far as tree nuts go, from now on I will be teaching the kids that they are a fruit.  I never said I was a perfect teacher.  I get things wrong, too.  But at least in our "school" tomatoes (and ketchup) don't count as a veggie.  ;)
        
  • @Irtrauth that's really unfortunate. It's not that hard to cheaply make good tasting, healthy food. Sometimes even more so when you're cooking in bulk. 
    Btw I have cotton candy blue hair IRL right now, and it's pretty awesome.
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker 

    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • lbonga1 said:
    It's not that hard to cheaply make good tasting, healthy food. Sometimes even more so when you're cooking in bulk. 
    To bring this full circle, you're so right.  The evidence is in my pantry photo up there!!!
        
  • DC2London said:
    lrtrauth said:
    I'm just putting this out there,... I don't believe that a coconut is a tree nut; its a fruit. The FDA lumps it into the tree nut category, but not all individuals with tree nut allergies are allergic to coconut.
    Touche.  Although, as a food allergy family, we consider coconut a tree nut, as does our allergist and family doc.  We also have friends with tree nut allergies that react to coconut (and not just when ingested - even when in cosmetic products), so I guess that's where we're coming from.

    But thanks for correcting me.  I'll be sure to remember to pass the info along to the kids ;)
    Interesting.  Our allergists do not (either of them, Jack's or Rhys') treat coconut as a tree nut.  They consider it a stone fruit.  Further proof that the world of food allergies is fraught with disagreement :/  Not that that makes it difficult for those of us trying to keep our kids healthy.  Nope, not at all ;)
    Agreed, since my child's allergies are all "hypoallergenic."  And on the coconut subject, my nephew's reacts horribly to coconut in cosmetics
This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards
"
"