Hi ladies- im Ashley, 32.5 weeks pregnant with #3, our first little girl.. husband and I are having a HORRIBLE time naming this little girl. So much so that when referring to her, we call her baby no name

I absolutely adore the name Hattie and he hates it. Our middle name is set in stone, Mae after his grandma who passed away a year ago. He likes Ava, Ella (both are way too popular for my taste) and Allison (which is completely random to me because it is just very late 1980s to me) and he ddoesn't see how I can like Hattie and not like Allison.. our boys are Colin & Brock, so their names are not super common but are also not totally out there either and I want to follow that path with our daughter, but the struggle is real!! So basically I'm open to any and all suggestions! Thanks!
Re: struggling
I love Etta Mae. I would use Etta myself if it didn't sound weird with our last name.
You might consider...
Clara Mae*

Isla Mae
Nora Mae
Ruby Mae*
*also on our current short list.
Precious baby boy "HC" born May 2013.
Heidi
Eden
Elise
Suggestions:
Clara
Vera
Lucille/Lucy
Juno
Edith (Edie is adorable)
Cora
Teresa/Tessa
Willa
Heidi
Helen
Elsie
Eva
Alice
I also can't stand the nn Allie...reminds me of a dirty cat.
I love the suggestion of Etta and Clara.
Clara is on our short list as well.
Have you considered Mae as the first name?