Opinions please!

jnnfrrose6

We're team green and are having a difficult time coming together on a girl's name. I'm just looking for some feedback on our current list. They are in no particular order. DS is Sean and we have a McLastname. TIA! Elizabeth Anne Margaret Katherine Bridget Susan Kimberly ETA sorry for the formatting. I'm on my iPad and don't know how to fix it!

WashingtonQueen

I like Bridget and then Katherine. Margaret is ok but I like the names derived from it better (Greta, Maggie).

Solstice7118

I love the names Katherine, Elizabeth, and Margaret. Probably in that order. Have you thought about nicknames (or lack thereof)? In my family we have 3 Katherine's and one is Katie, one Kathy, and one Katherine. We have 3 Margaret's and two are Maggie and one is Peggy. And we have 3 Elizabeth's (though 2 are middle names) - the first name goes by Liz (though I've heard Beth and really like that, too). There's also Eliza (like in Pride and Prejudice). If you hate nicknames, I think Anne or Bridget are pretty names. I'm not a fan of Kimberly or Susan, but that's just me. Good luck!

Manderlin923

Bridget is my favorite!

Cricket Bug

Bridget is my favourite too!

lovesmonkey

mjreilly2 said:

Love Elizabeth, Anne, Margaret, Katherine, and Bridget. I think Bridget and Sean make a good sibset.

Really don't care for Kimberly or Susan — too "dated" for my liking (just not a fan of that time period of names).

This!

jnnfrrose6

Thanks for the feedback ladies! Bridget is DH's favorite. I'm still warming up to it. Kimberly is also one of his choices which I put on the list for him, but I agree it's a super 80's name. Susan is a family name, though it'll probably be a MN if we use it at all. DH also loves Margaret, but I struggle with it paired with our McLN (it's a McG...) name so it seems like a tongue twister to me. The remainder seem pretty classic to me which is why I'm struggling with a first choice!

CallaLily25

This is how I would rank them:

1. Elizabeth

2. Bridget

3. Margaret 

4. Katherine 

Kimberly: sounds a little dated to me. 

Susan: dislike. 

Anne: Classic, but a little plan. I love Anna, though!

lauralew

I like all of them, except Kimberly for the same reasons as PP. I also love Bridgid as an alternative to Bridget. Which I totes think you could do with a Mc last name.