*****Edited from original post***********
Ok, it’s time to play: What I Learned on TheBump.com – Baby Shower message board!
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
1)
Baby showers (and all showers for that matter) are, by general
consensus, defined as a gift-giving event. The main purpose of these
events is to “shower” the Mother-to-be/guest of honor with gifts, and
then sit around in a circle watching her open said gifts.
Comment:
I truly did not understand this, thank you to those of you who
thoughtfully and politely explained this to me. (I really do appreciate
that the majority of answers on here weren’t rude, spiteful or inane.)
2)
Based on the above definition, I find the idea of showers in general to
be tacky, and to be honest, I’m now glad I’m not having one.
I
will never again consider the idea of throwing a shower for myself, and
would politely decline if someone wanted to throw one for me. I would
never want a friend/relative of mine to go through all the trouble and
expense of throwing me a party, and then demanding that guests bring
gifts for me, (and sit around watching me open them (ewww!)) I would
also never feel comfortable throwing a shower for someone else; since I
would never want to invite people to a party and demand they bring
gifts, even if it was for a friend!
Comment: This will
probably offend many people on here since it is a baby shower message
board, but since you all made me understand what a shower is, it has
changed my opinion of them forever, and it’s quite simply how I feel.
It’s my opinion, and you are welcome to have a different one.
3) Many people on this message board have a very narrow definition of what a birthday party is.
Comment:
I accept a the very narrow definition of showers presented to me on
here because I don’t have any evidence to the contrary, but I will
reject your narrow definition of a birthday party because I have plenty
of evidence to the contrary: Where I am from in the USA and where I
currently live in Germany, birthday parties are NOT about gifts, and it
would be considered RUDE to let someone else throw you a birthday party.
It’s
YOUR birthday, if YOU want a party, you should organize and pay for it
yourself. If you invite your friends out somewhere, YOU should pay for
their meals or drinks. If you throw a party, you should make sure that
all your guest have enough to eat and drink, and that they are
entertained. Some people might give you gifts, some people might not,
and often they will just bring flowers or chocolate or wine as a thank
you for hosting a party. If someone does bring you a (wrapped) gift,
you ask them if they want you to open it, if they do then you open it
immediately and thank them immediately. You DO NOT EVER sit around open
all your gifts at once in front of everybody as it would be considered
highly rude as an adult to do this.
So, to all of the people that
think the idea of throwing your own birthday party is “soooo
disgustingly tacky”, please see #4. I don’t know if you don’t celebrate
your birthday (that’s sad), or if you just happen to have people in
your life who want to throw parties for you all the time (if so nice for
you, but logistically quite unlikely or impossible for many (If any one
of my friends tried to throw a party for me, at least half of my
friends would not be invited to said party, due to the fact that I have
multiple circles of friends)), or if you invite your friends out and
make them pay for their own meals/drinks while expecting them to bring
you gifts (fine if that isn’t considered rude where you are from), but I
assume you know the social norms of birthday parties in your
culture/circle of friends better than I do. Please don’t assume you know
the social norms of birthday parties in my culture/circle of friends
better than I do.
4) Many people on this message
board seem to think that manners and etiquette are universal rules set
in stone that apply to and are the same for the whole entire world.
Comment: They are not! Get over yourself and your ethnocentrism!
5)
There are a few people on here who either can’t read, or refuse to try
to understand what anyone else has written. They just assume they know
what other people are thinking, and if anyone dares to challenge what
they say with criticism, the respond by being rude and more or less name
calling.
Comment: When behavior like this is allowed to
run rampant on message boards, it ruins the whole community for
everyone. It drives away all the intelligent people who are willing to
have civilized conversations and invites trolling and flame wars.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
This is the very last I’m going to reply in this topic, or in this section of The Bump forums
I
know there might be some who will insist on getting the last word in,
so they can feel smug and most likely they will be the people I was
referring to in #5.
To the majority of you who gave polite, helpful answers, thank you for your advice!
Tschüs! :-h
Re: HELP!! Should I have a Baby Shower in Germany??
Just a warning....the other ladies here will probably flame you because throwing yourself any kind of gift giving party is a huge no no, most especially baby showers.
If no one wants to throw one for you, then you don't get to have one. This is /really/ true when you are in a culture that doesn't have the baby shower tradition. you'd be asking all these women, who have never even heard of a shower, to buy you gifts and then watch you open them.
If someone wants to get you something, they will. if your family in the US wants to throw you a shower, great. if not, then no shower. sorry. when you decide to have a LO, always expect to buy all of your own stuff. it's a nice surprise when someone is generous and gives you a gift, but you can never ever ever ask for a gift or throw yourself a shower.
And I still don't get how it's different than throwing yourself a Bithday party...
BFP 1- EDD 2/09/11 Missed MC DX @11 weeks D&C- 7/25/10 BFP 2- EDD 12/22/11 Natural MC @ 5w 2d BFP 3- EDD 1/25/12 DD Josephine born 1/16/12
And never ever should you consider throwing one for yourself. Tacky x100. You need to abandon the idea of having a shower and move on.
Also, I never understand the comparison of baby showers to birthday parties (or weddings for that matter). I don't know many adults that throw themselves a birthday party, but those that do don't do it for the sole purpose of collecting gifts. I have never been to an adult "birthday party" where gifts were expected.
OP, maybe you don't realize it, but a baby shower is solely to shower the MTB with gifts. So you are essentially asking your friends to come bring you gifts. You say they would probably find it cute to be involved in an American tradition, but I expect they would actually referring to you more along the lines of another "tacky American".
I'm sad I'll never get to experience this tradition though.
https://thediaryofsugarandspice.wordpress.com/2013/09/17/an-american-baby-shower-for-a-german-baby/
What if I threw a "no-gifts baby shower"?
Second, asking people to buy stuff for you is extremely rude. And that's what you'd be doing if you threw your own shower.
Third, and only because you mentioned it more than once, buy your own stuff. Of course "it would nice", but that's just too bad. Your baby...you buy her diapers and clothes.
Then invite your friends over for some food and games. Doesn't need to be related to your procreation.
So I was genuinely confused because I didn't realize the soul purpose of a baby shower is gifts.
I thought the purpose of a baby shower was to get together with women and share hopes and experiences and well wishes for the up coming birth, and celebrating womanhood, not about "showering "someone with gifts.
I'm definitely wanting one less and less now because you all make it sound horribly selfish even if someone else were to throw one for you!
I won't be having a shower.
I will never stop throwing kick ass parties for my birthday sometimes though, since I don't want to deprive my friends of all the awesome good times! They would be truly dissapointed. I throw myself birthday parties because I love my friends and want to see them all and hang out with them, not because I expect gifts or attention. I was foolish to think that philosophy would transfer to another kind of event. I don't expect you to understand.
But remember there are other parts of the world with different cultures and different ways of doing things and different ideas of proper etiquette. Even within the United States the rules of society vary greatly from region to region.
This last reply crossed a line in meanness, in my opinion.
OP, you really can't have a shower there unless someone offers one and then I'd only invite people who actually understand showers, not just heard of them. It does come across as strange to invite someone to an event they don't know much about & then explain to them it means coming to give you baby gifts...know what I mean?
I think a meet the baby party would be nice, around 4 to 10 weeks out. I think you could have simple plans in place before baby is born so you don't have to do much after baby arrives.
I think regardless of not having a shower, people will give you little gifts. If you want to gush about pregnancy, I'd invite a friend with kids of her own out to lunch or something. She will be able to relate & gush about baby stuff with you.
and share hopes and experiences and well wishes for the up coming birth
I have never, ever been to a shower like this. Ever. Showers, in my experience, involve basic socializing, food, maybe some games, opening of the gifts.
I mean, yes, I'll say to the MTB "I'm so excited for you! I can't wait to meet the baby.", but that's all of 2 seconds. There are general "well wishes".
But showers aren't this kum by yah experience of women sitting around and talking about their birth experiences and sharing their hopes for this upcoming kid. Hell- if I had gone to a shower like this BEFORE I became a mother, this would have been the 9th circle of hell!
Don't overblow the importance of a shower. It's a social event primarily focused on giving the MTB gifts for the baby.
AND I would even argue that if showers were this "sharing" thing, as they aren't common in Germany, women would be even MORE "WTF" about it if they came.
I would wait until after baby arrives & host a party then.
The difference is that you are hosting for your baby (who is the guest of honor after they are born) vs. throwing a gift giving event for yourself.
It's not a crime to want a baby shower, but it is one to throw your own.
LFAF Summer 2016 Awards:
Let me get this straight:
I say I'm not going to have a shower.
To which you insist on replying with the most inane reason as to why I shouldn't have a shower (which I just agreed not to have).
I then laugh at your reasoning because it's seriously one of the dumbest things I have ever heard.
According to you I am "butt hurt" and going to throw myself a shower anyway.
According to your friend, I don't like the answer to the question I asked and am calling everyone mean for not understanding that I'm special.
.....
Logic and reasoning are clearly one of your strong suits!
Im sorry you won't get a baby shower, but if it's not typical in Germany, then you just have to accept that. Many people will still bring you gifts when baby is born, and you can have a meet the baby party.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
1) Baby showers (and all showers for that matter) are, by general consensus, defined as a gift-giving event. The main purpose of these events is to “shower” the Mother-to-be/guest of honor with gifts, and then sit around in a circle watching her open said gifts.
Comment: I truly did not understand this, thank you to those of you who thoughtfully and politely explained this to me. (I really do appreciate that the majority of answers on here weren’t rude, spiteful or inane.)
2) Based on the above definition, I find the idea of showers in general to be tacky, and to be honest, I’m now glad I’m not having one.
I will never again consider the idea of throwing a shower for myself, and would politely decline if someone wanted to throw one for me. I would never want a friend/relative of mine to go through all the trouble and expense of throwing me a party, and then demanding that guests bring gifts for me, (and sit around watching me open them (ewww!)) I would also never feel comfortable throwing a shower for someone else; since I would never want to invite people to a party and demand they bring gifts, even if it was for a friend!
Comment: This will probably offend many people on here since it is a baby shower message board, but since you all made me understand what a shower is, it has changed my opinion of them forever, and it’s quite simply how I feel. It’s my opinion, and you are welcome to have a different one.
3) Many people on this message board have a very narrow definition of what a birthday party is.
Comment: I accept a the very narrow definition of showers presented to me on here because I don’t have any evidence to the contrary, but I will reject your narrow definition of a birthday party because I have plenty of evidence to the contrary: Where I am from in the USA and where I currently live in Germany, birthday parties are NOT about gifts, and it would be considered RUDE to let someone else throw you a birthday party.
It’s YOUR birthday, if YOU want a party, you should organize and pay for it yourself. If you invite your friends out somewhere, YOU should pay for their meals or drinks. If you throw a party, you should make sure that all your guest have enough to eat and drink, and that they are entertained. Some people might give you gifts, some people might not, and often they will just bring flowers or chocolate or wine as a thank you for hosting a party. If someone does bring you a (wrapped) gift, you ask them if they want you to open it, if they do then you open it immediately and thank them immediately. You DO NOT EVER sit around open all your gifts at once in front of everybody as it would be considered highly rude as an adult to do this.
So, to all of the people that think the idea of throwing your own birthday party is “soooo disgustingly tacky”, please see #4. I don’t know if you don’t celebrate your birthday (that’s sad), or if you just happen to have people in your life who want to throw parties for you all the time (if so nice for you, but logistically quite unlikely or impossible for many (If any one of my friends tried to throw a party for me, at least half of my friends would not be invited to said party, due to the fact that I have multiple circles of friends)), or if you invite your friends out and make them pay for their own meals/drinks while expecting them to bring you gifts (fine if that isn’t considered rude where you are from), but I assume you know the social norms of birthday parties in your culture/circle of friends better than I do. Please don’t assume you know the social norms of birthday parties in my culture/circle of friends better than I do.
4) Many people on this message board seem to think that manners and etiquette are universal rules set in stone that apply to and are the same for the whole entire world.
Comment: They are not! Get over yourself and your ethnocentrism!
5) There are a few people on here who either can’t read, or refuse to try to understand what anyone else has written. They just assume they know what other people are thinking, and if anyone dares to challenge what they say with criticism, the respond by being rude and more or less name calling.
Comment: When behavior like this is allowed to run rampant on message boards, it ruins the whole community for everyone. It drives away all the intelligent people who are willing to have civilized conversations and invites trolling and flame wars.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
This is the very last I’m going to reply in this topic, or in this section of The Bump forums
I know there might be some who will insist on getting the last word in, so they can feel smug and most likely they will be the people I was referring to in #5.
To the majority of you who gave polite, helpful answers, thank you for your advice!
Tschüs! :-h
LFAF Summer 2016 Awards: