Cookie Butter

jackdustin

Can't remember who mentioned this amazing food but I sent my husband to Trader Joes to find it so I could try it for myself...all I can say is THANK YOU, THANK YOU, THANK YOU for introducing this yumminess into my life

TheBeeCharmer

You're welcome.  

MrsLeanna

I LOVE the cookie and cocoa swirl spread on strawberries! I had some today actually  

keeumm

YES! I just mentioned this in a post and I, too, want to say thank you for mentioning it. I had never heard of it before, but now it's changed my life. 

Also, the cocoa and cookie butter mix is my new favorite food. It's taking all my will power not to go get the jar right now.

SurprisePartySue

WHAT!? What is this thing you call Cookie butter!? Can you only get it at a Trader Joes? My current obsession is cookie dough ice cream.

jjtyler

MeaganStringer said:

WHAT!? What is this thing you call Cookie butter!? Can you only get it at a Trader Joes? My current obsession is cookie dough ice cream.

Same thing here (I just ate some cookie dough myself)...what is this Cookie Butter and why is it so delightful?

jjtyler

MeaganStringer said:

WHAT!? What is this thing you call Cookie butter!? Can you only get it at a Trader Joes? My current obsession is cookie dough ice cream.

Same thing here (I just ate some cookie dough myself)...what is this Cookie Butter and why is it so delightful?

TheBeeCharmer

I order it on Amazon. No Trader Joe's near us.... 

Lizmullen

What does one put cookie butter on?

lrmrtn

jackdustin said:

Can't remember who mentioned this amazing food but I sent my husband to Trader Joes to find it so I could try it for myself...all I can say is THANK YOU, THANK YOU, THANK YOU for introducing this yumminess into my life

I second this! We got the crunchy one this weekend and it takes all my willpower to not eat it all day long.

@Lizmullen, the question is really what does one NOT put cookie butter on?!  So far we have tried it the following ways, all with great success:

a spoon

cat cookies from Trader Joes (might as well maximize the trip!)

skinny cow ice cream sandwiches (if you didn't think cookie butter could get any better...)

 

daizijayne

Ooooh.  I bought some cookie butter yesterday after reading all about here.  All I can say is YUM.  So far I've only eaten it on a spoon.  Off to rummage through my pantry to see what other dipping foods I can find.

sheriot

Yes! Thank you! I bought my first jar last night and it's amazing. My H tasted it and immediately smiled like a little kid. He then proceeded to eat more just so he could figure out "exactly what it tastes like." It tastes like awesome.

jackdustin

@irmrtn what are these cat cookies you speak of?

dakota01

OMG love this stuff! I grill up some banana and cookie butter sandwiches and sprinkle with cinnamon sugar! Amazing!

lrmrtn

@jackdustin, they sell cat cookies at trader joe's.  They are little cookies in the shape of cats that come in several different flavors - ginger, cinnamon and I think chocolate.  They are pretty low cal for cookies and I think they have a decent serving size, like 15 (if you stick to the serving size...).  They are really yummy and good if you need a little something sweet.  We are partial to ginger.

jackdustin

Well...looks like another trip to trader joes this weekend...thanks @irmrtn!

lrmrtn

LOL enjoy!  Trader Joe's has way too many yummy things!

Bootsie327

What do you guys put the cookie butter on? The last time I got it was before I was pg, and I couldn't figure out what it would taste good on, so I'd just eat it by the spoonful and feel guilty. Haha. Something tells me I'd have no problems with that right now, though!

jackdustin

Yup so far a spoon is all I need

Unknown

This content has been removed.

mrstengallonhat1

Can someone explain to me what this tastes like?  Is it a cookie dough flavor or something else? 

annabeanybee

If you want to feel like you're not being totally decadent, it's AMAZING on sliced apples. And I think I need to go make a cookie butter/banana sandwich now. :P

lrmrtn

A spoon is all you need! I could see it being really good on apples or toast too.

it tastes like spreadable butter cookies with a hint of ginger to me.That's the only way I can think to describe it. It is amazing!

Bootsie327

MrsKTen said:

Can someone explain to me what this tastes like?  Is it a cookie dough flavor or something else? 

It tastes more like oatmeal cookie...but like PB consistency. It's quite heavenly!!

Lizmullen

You had me at ice cream sandwiches and apples... I might die

Jillzy86

This sounds wonderful! Next time I shop at Trader Joes, I'm looking for it!