Girls list

TikiTurtle

Same as the boys, no particular order.

Scarlett&Gatsby

All of these are refreshing, but I especially love Brynn, Gemma and Sonia. I voted for Brynn (I like its simplicity), but they're all really nice.

Empireceo

Love Sonia, nice alternative to the ever present Sophia/Sophie.

bobcee

I voted Gemma, but I also really like Jocelyn and Sonia.

apc1929

I love Erin    Have really positive associations with all the Erin's I know though!  

nittanyllama

Love Erin, Brynn, and Rosalyn.

WashingtonQueen

I adore Jocelyn! I like Gemma too.

kronea

Gemma and Brynn

BlessedMomma07

Brynn is my favorite from your list! It was one of my top picks but was voted down by DH

queenbone

I voted for Rosalyn, but I prefer Rosalind

TikiTurtle

So much for help narrowing down my list

But thanks for all the feedback!

zitrone

I adore Gemma! If I didn't have a cousin named Jenna, it would totally be a top name for me. Like PPs, I like Rosalyn but MUCh prefer spelling Rosalind. It looks more classic and yet unique since -lyn is is a popular ending now (Madelyn, Jocelyn, etc) Jocelyn and Brynn are NMS but they are my third and forth pick from your list.