I've used both and the mamaroo is the way to go. It has multiple settings for both the swing and sounds. Plus it plugs in. I love the fact that LO falls asleep in it. It is amazing.
TTC January 2010
BFP #1 10-11-10 ectopic discovered 10-22-10,
10-23-10 methotrexate & emergency surgery, lost right tube BFP #2
12-1-10 Found to be tissue dropped from salingectomy or missed heterotopic
pregnancy from BFP #1 BFP #3 1-30-11 DS arrived on due date 10-10-11 BFP
#4 Surprise 9-3-12 EDD 5-9-13 DS2 arrived 5-5-13 BFP #5 5-14-14 Emergency D&C 6-16-14 9 weeks
I'm the odd one out, my DS much preferred the swing. it had a bigger range of motion, and the mamaroo was too slow for him. we had a swing that plugged in...
Warning
No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
We were going to register for Mamaroo and NOT a swing. Took it off our registry when our friends, who have triplets, could not calm any of their three children in the Mamaroo. We will be inheriting their Mamaroo, they got it second hand from a set of twins that also did not like it. It is to my understanding that most babies either love it or hate it, a lot of money to spend if your baby does not like it. Most babies seem to like a traditional swing, we will be registering for a plug in model.
TTC since 10/09
Me-43 DH-44
RE and testing 10/10-11/10, Recommending IVF
1/11 New RE
AMA and DOR-DH low motility
IVF #1.1 cancelled 3/11 due to poor response IVF #1.2 May 2011, one perfect 8-cell embryo, 3dt-BFN, IVF #2.1 Converted to IUI d/t poor response. New RE 9/2011. IVF 2.2 completed using HGH,EPP,DHEA, Q-10 and accupuncture. Transferred one 8-cell, grade one embryo on 10/19. BFP 10/31/11 Chemical pregancy on 11/2/11. Started stims for IVF #3, our final try, on 12-2-11. ET on 12/18. Transferred 3 Grade A embryos-BFFN Planning DE IVF, late March/early April- Donors ER expected to be 4/2-4/4.
PAIF/SAIF welcome
I'm the odd one out, my DS much preferred the swing. it had a bigger range of motion, and the mamaroo was too slow for him. we had a swing that plugged in...
im with you. we had both she didnt like the mamaroo as much it was slow and now at comfortable as the snug bunny. im so much happier with the swing.
BFP #1: 7/18/12, M/C 8/6/12@6weeksMissing our April Angel
Re: Mamaroo vs swing