For you parents who use CIO or any form of sleep training when you say the first night was tough what do you mean exactly? Do you mean the initial cry to go to sleep was hard or the many wake ups per the usual? In the MOTN how long did you wait to go to the crib to soothe ( ie put the paci in or pat your LO back)? How long would you let that go on?
My experience last night was not as bad as I thought it would be. No real crying for bed mostly just a short period of whining or grunting. I finally rolled him onto his side at the last check and he was out. When he gets frustrated he usually wants the help to roll. Am I supposed to assist him in this manner to help him sleep? Also in the MOTN he woke up 3 times with is 3 less than usual! I was thrilled. However once I heard him fussing and it woke me up I went to him, rolled him to a comfy position either back or belly and placed my hand on him for a few minutes and he fell back asleep. This all worked except after his MOTN feed which was later than usual for him at 6 am. I then swaddled him and placed in the RNP where he slept 2 more hours. Did I do the MOTN right? Should I let him figure it out more before rushing in? I was trying to avoid the big cries in the MOTN.
Please no judgment here. I am respectful of all parenting styles and wish for the same in return.
Re: CIO users
I think like the other poster said consistency is the most important thing for them. I don't pick him up after I've put him down. We don't use a paci so I don't know about that.
I always give him a couple minutes to try and work it out before going in to him. I don't want to rush in at every peep or small cry because lots of time he'll put himself back. And then I start checks based on ferbers times.
I think you should pick a method, study up on and go for it.
TTC since May 2006. After 3 failed Clomid cycles, 2 failed Injectibles/IUIs, 2 failed IVFs and 1 failed FET, we moved on to adoption!
Last ditch FET resulted in BFP, and identical twin girls!
For MOTN for us I would go in right away to calm her down if it was a real cry and not just quiet fussing (so she didn't wake up DD1!) and then I'd try to head back out before she was totally asleep. If she started crying/whining after I left, I gave her about 5 minutes before going back in again. We've gone from waking every 2 hours to waking for just one feeding (and one night she actually slept straight through the night).