for almost every single nap -- i have to lay dd in our bed and lay
w/her...usually w/a bottle until she falls asleep (or rock her w/a
bottle) and then transfer her to her crib. lately she has been fighting
me SO hard at nap time and i know she is tired. i tried putting her
down earlier and later and she still fights me. it's a battle twice a
day. =(
Re: xp: does nap time get better w/age?
It took a very long time - DD was about 16 mos before she started putting herself to sleep. I never tried CIO because it's not my temperament, but I tried a lot of different things and nothing seemed to work. One day, it just kind of "clicked" for her - I think it was just her time to start putting herself to sleep.
I can say that sitting in her room while she was in her crib did NOT work. We tried it every night for over a week and she was absolutely hysterical. Now that she's older, a bedtime routine works wonders but it didn't seem to make a difference when she was your DD's age.
When DD was about 12/13 mos, she also started really fighting naps. It would take 1-2 hours to put her to sleep for naps, and 2+ hours at night. This went on for over a month. Finally I figured out she was trying to drop her AM nap. So we gradually moved back the first nap, and it got shorter and shorter. Now she takes one long afternoon nap only.
Hopefully your process will be much shorter! I really feel if I had tried dropping one of her naps earlier, the whole process would not have been so drawn out (and exhausting).
DD was able to fall asleep on her own at bedtime around 10.5 months. We never did CIO or sleep training, that was finally the age I was able to put her down "drowsy but awake" and she went to sleep on her own. I think she fussed and whimpered for a few minutes, but there wasn't any screaming or hard crying involved.
A month or two after we had that bedtime routine in place we were able to do the same thing for naps. Sometime she would still nurse before naps, but she wouldn't fall totally asleep in my arms, just get drowsy.
We still have periods when she fights bedtime and naptime (usually during developmental spurts or teething), but they are just phases, and it usually just involves some extra rocking and comforting to get her through.
I never had that problem with Jack. Not even when he was a baby. I hope it gets easier for you.
If you are open to it, I would try CIO. Your daughter is old enough to go down on her own without a bottle. Besides a bottle of milk before going to sleep is bad for her teeth unless you are brushing after the bottle before she falls asleep. I would start a routine with a couple books during her bottle, brushing or at least having her drink water to clear the milk from her mouth, night night time and leave the room.