September 2022 Moms

Product Spotlight: Baby Monitors

Recommendations and questions.
Current pregnancy -
First BFP on 1/4/22.  Due date 9/13/22.

Four prior losses, no living children - 1 first trimester miscarriage, 1 blighted ovum, 1 chemical, and one extreme premature live birth daughter who died at 15 days old.


Re: Product Spotlight: Baby Monitors

  • We use the Nanit and while I hated it at first (the volume on Android was awful), it's loads better now and we plan to use it for the second baby as well. We started with a vTech audio only monitor and it was great, and we still keep it on in our daughter's room so we don't run down the battery on our phones with Nanit.

    The one con with Nanit is that to monitor with it, you have to use your phone. We keep it up on our Android tablet once she's in bed for the night and that helps, but yeah, definitely a con. On the flip side, though, we can pop in and view her from our phone when she's overnight at the grandparent's house!

    Bonus is that you can use HSA funds to buy it through their site, because it includes breathing wear, which is a comfort to have. 
    DD 10/2019
  • Loading the player...
  • I opted for a low tech Motorola one. Not sure what it's called but it was $100 just does video and sound and not connected to the internet. Too many creepy stories about the ones connected to the internet for me. And I feel some how my MIL would be given access when watching baby and she wouldn't stop so she would watch the baby sleep all the time and that's just creepy too, especially because baby sleeps in our room.

    I do wish it had a larger screen, a better picture, and longer range, but for how little I've used it, it's fine. I only used it when my babies were very little and I wouldn't hear them crying and wanted to be outside in the summer at the camp fire. We contact nap for the most part and then when I'm working I go to bed with them so don't have much use for it. When they start sleeping in their own beds, they can walk and come find us when they need us. 
  • @jhysmath I’m on the same page as you regarding wifi connected monitors. 

    Our 2 main criteria when buying for our son was:
    1. Not to need wifi to connect (which means to also have a separate monitor and not need our phones for it). We actually have multiple friends who had idiots drive around their neighborhoods, hack into their wifi, and then scream crazy stuff through the monitor to their sleeping babies. It caused a lot of lasting fear of sleeping alone. Not okay!! 
    2. It needed to have 2 cameras. Even if you only plan to have one baby, having the second camera is amazing. One camera you can have set up in your nursery and the second can travel in your diaper bag should baby go over to the grandparents or you’re on a trip and have a separate room for baby. That way you can still enjoy your vacation while seeing and hearing that your baby is okay in the other room. We will use the second camera for this new baby when they’re born and will get a separate one camera one to still have in the diaper bag for overnights elsewhere. Oh and also note that the models change so much that even if you buy with one camera and then decide you want a second, it’s really hard to buy it separately later. 

    With that said, researching for baby monitors is so tricky. For every rave review you have a very bad one so I couldn’t find one that was absolutely perfect (and not way too overpriced) and just weighed the pros and cons that mattered to us. We ended up with the Motorola VM75-2 (2 means the one with 2 cameras) and actually really like it. We charge it well before bed and it lasts a solid 10-11 hrs overnight and then 2-3 hours for nap. It has a large screen and good night vision and isn’t very expensive.  
  • We have a very simple, sound only monitor. Works for us and though at times I wished I could see her, I think watching her could very easily have gotten obsessive for me. 
  • For those concerned with hacking, that was a fear of ours too. However, while any monitor has the potential to be hacked, Nanit has a much higher level of encryption and is therfore more difficult to hack.

    My husband is a software engineer and we did a lot of research before deciding on this. Here's a good article on it: https://smarthomestarter.com/can-nanit-be-hacked-tips-on-how-to-stay-secure/

    Here's another good article for information on monitors that are much higher risk: https://motherhoodhq.com/baby-monitor-hacked/
    DD 10/2019
  • Hey ladies, 
    This is a topic I've been waiting for!!! I'm looking for one with no wifi (I really do not want it to connect to our phones!!! I'm addicted enough as it is.), video and sound! Reading above, I guess another feature would be that it can be portable enough to move the camera from room to room (or to another place entirely!) but not too difficult to set up/angle at baby.
    Any recommendations?? (Aside from those stated above) 
  • We were looking at the Miku. Does anyone have experience?
  • We were looking at the Miku. Does anyone have experience?
    No opinion, but I know it was on our short list of ones we were considering last time, so it must have had great features.
    DD 10/2019
  • We registered for this one: 

    Infant Optics DXR-8 PRO Baby Monitor 720P 5" HD Display with A.N.R. (Active Noise Reduction), White


    I didn’t want a wifi one due to Comcast sucking. I also didn’t want one that went to my phone in case I needed to use the phone for something else. 

    I’ll definitely have to see how to get a second camera, though. Thanks to those who suggested it. Amazon questions says it is a possibility for this one. 
  • I think we're going for the Owlet duo, for heartbeat monitoring. I don't want to entirely dismiss the security concerns, but I can't find a single instance of an Owlet hack that didn't end with, "if they had changed the password from the default it wouldn't have happened." Am I guaranteed a positive and hack-free experience? No...but given my concerns about this baby having an elevated risk of a cardiac issue, it's an acceptable trade-off in my mind.
    First time mom-to-be, due 9/25/22

    Some complicated chromosomal stuff going on - our fingers are crossed, but this may not go according to plan!

  • I'm glad I'm not the only one who doesn't like the wifi ones. I thought maybe I was overly paranoid and anxious. It probably also helped that we didn't have internet access at our ny home until this past summer when a company finally ran lines through our town. 
  • We’re going with the nanit. Our neighbors have one and they’ve loved it. When I’ve watched their daughter it’s been a great tool to use too- so nice to have it be able to connect to your phone. 

    I was a little worried about hacking, but honestly so much of our life is already online there are much worse things that could be hacked (bank, apps, phone, Alexa/Google homes, computer, etc…) imo.
  • @lilienne I’ve heard great things about the owlet from a friend who has one. They say just don’t actually wash the sock, but maybe the newer ones are washable?
  • @lilienne we have been considering the owlet as well since my husband has a genetic heart condition. I think it will help give us a peace of mind
  • @lucyg00cy thanks for passing that along! It does look like the socks are a bit of a hassle to wash, but I think that's probably a price I'm willing to pay. Still, I'm glad you warned me - it would suck to ruin it because I wasn't prewarned!

    @wendy-g yikes, sorry to hear you and your husband have to worry about this, too. I'm kind of a data nerd, so the sleep/heart rate/temperature data might have sucked me in no matter what. Owlet sound especially appealing for those of us expecting kids who might genuinely need some extra monitoring.
    First time mom-to-be, due 9/25/22

    Some complicated chromosomal stuff going on - our fingers are crossed, but this may not go according to plan!

  • @lilienne I know a girl with a young babe (about 6 months old) who had breathing issues while sick with a cold and the Owlet is what triggered that he needed to be seen asap. He's okay now, but he was in the hospital for several days. I absolutely think this is a great investment for your peace of mind.
    DD 10/2019
  • @trapperkeeper87 how scary! I'm so glad it turned out okay. I know medical data is a seriously double-edged sword, but I'm pretty okay with the trade offs given our particular situation.
    First time mom-to-be, due 9/25/22

    Some complicated chromosomal stuff going on - our fingers are crossed, but this may not go according to plan!

  • I just want to share that we have bought 2 Netvue Cameras ($30) approx and they are the best thing ever. High quality, I can access the cameras from anywhere. We have 2 Alexa shows we pull the baby room up on depending on what room we are in. Fantastic image quality and dependability  and you absolutely can’t beat the cost. 

  • Does anyone have a VAVA monitor? They have great reviews and that's what we're leaning towards.

  • @Fluffy1187 a few moms in my other bump group got it and love it! I couldn’t find it in Canada though, womp womp 👎🏻 
  • @newbabymama27
    Thanks for the tip on 2 cameras! After you mentioned that, I realized how convenient it would be to have one spare to keep in the diaper bag for visits to family and friends. 

    I really don't need all the bells and whistles. Battery life and range are most important, with a decent screen resolution. No WiFi preferred. We don't have a huge yard, but I'd like to be able to be outside when the little one is napping. The Motorola ones are most appealing due to price and functions, but the reviews trend toward negative...and battery life doesn't seem to get a good rating. 
    Anyone have any experience with this one? Looks like pairing a second camera is pretty simple, and looks like the range is about 900ft (compared with a Motorola that has 1000ft range). 
    https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B07N428WP1/ref=ask_ql_qh_dp_hza
  • @mnmomma84 glad I could help on the 2 camera tip! No input on the one you linked but I do have the Motorola VM75-2 and after almost 2.5 years of daily use, battery lasts all night (7:30pm-6:30am) and between 1-2 hours for nap time. Then we either plug it in to get through nap or simply a couple of hours in the evening before bed and it’s good to go again. I think that’s pretty impressive but I’ll just leave you to make your call 😊 
  • I don't want to be the bearer of bad news, but I do want people to be properly informed: traditional baby monitors can be hacked just like Wi-Fi ones can. It's worth arguing, actually, that monitors such as Nanit are safer because a hacker would need both your router password as well as your Nanit password. A traditional monitor can be hacked if someone is within range and can figure out the frequency your monitor is working on (scanners can easily figure this out).

    Yes, both Wi-Fi and traditional monitors have both pros and cons, but the hacking potential is present on both. If someone can point me to research that shows I'm incorrect, I would love to read it; I like being a informed as possible!

    Oh, but the good news is that if you can find a monitor with channel or frequency hopping that is also from a reputable brand, that's a great way to decrease your chances of being hacked.
    DD 10/2019
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards
"
"