Jack and John sibset?

crf4 · July 2019

Hi there, pregnant with our fourth and team green. We have Brody, Jack and Rosalie. We potentially like the name John for a boy but is it odd to have both Jack and John considering Jack is a common nickname for John?

mb0112 · July 2019

I think they are too close. Do you have any other frontrunners?

daffodil_shoe · July 2019

Yes, sorry, it would be odd.

bellebaby221 · July 2019

Yeah I think so.
What about Jonathan?

crf4 · July 2019

Glad to know I’m not the only one, my husband was convinced they are very different lol. Struggling with boy names in general, we still have quite a bit of time left!

harpseal135 · July 2019

Um no, as I know Jack's that go as John and vice versa.......kind if odd to have brothers, though honestly I dont understand how Jack is a NN for john and I feel they are two entirely different names.