Isla is my favorite with your other kids names. I like Claire, but don't like the two C's with another initial, it feels unbalanced. Also suggesting...
To me, Reese is too much like Chase. Claire has a different feel to it to me than Quinn and Isla seems too "fluffy" comparatively. Honestly, Piper is better than any of them when placed beside your other kids names. How about:
I love Isla! Sloane would be my next favorite, then Claire, then Reese. PP's also had fantastic suggestions of Blair, Nora, Maren (I like it spelled Mairen), Lark and Calla. Whatever you choose, congrats and God bless!
The McC 3 - DH, (38) Me, (34) and DS (3) A.J.M. - Born 6/11/13 after 17 BFNs including 1 failed IUI. Maybe Baby #2 - Started TTC Feb 2015. Called it quits after 29 cycles.
Out of your list I like Claire but idk if I like it with Quinn and Chase. Suggesting Maeve, it's one of my favorites but one of my best friends just used it so I feel like I shouldn't. I'm also 34 weeks with my second pregnancy but third child (oldest is my stepson) and struggling to find a girls name we both love. Good luck deciding.
Sloane isn't my favorite name alone, but I think it works really well with your names (I really like Quinn!)... love suggestion for Sage and Blair... Scarlett and Sawyer also come to mind.
Re: Third Baby Name Help (Girl)
Adding:
Blair
Baby #2 Due 3/7/20
Nora
Greer
Brynn
Olive
Ivy
Elle
Britta
Bree
Sage
Mae
Fern
Natalie
Madison
Lyda
Nora
Greer
Bronwyn
Drew
Marin
Paige/Saige
Ivy
Lark
Rowan
Calla
Rory
A.J.M. - Born 6/11/13 after 17 BFNs including 1 failed IUI.
Maybe Baby #2 - Started TTC Feb 2015. Called it quits after 29 cycles.
Briar
Blair
Lilah
Wren
Willa
Our Angel: EDD: 05/11/17. MC at 6 weeks
Baby #2- EDD: 07/18/17
Claire is good, too. I also liked Drew from a PP's suggestion.
DSS born 01/2016
TTC since 01/2017
Letrozole + TI = BFP 01/30/2018 | EDD 10/11/2018
Lachlan
born March 2012
Suggestions:
Arden
Blythe