So I recently started a new job and my employer offers 2 different plans. Never had the option of choosing plans so I want some feedback. In the last 2 years, DH was hospitalized 1x for a staph infection (6 nights) and DS hospitalized 1x for an asthma attack (1 night). We owed $3k for DH and $1k for DS. Our current (soon to be old) coverage was a 600 deductible then 80/20 coinsurance. We paid $526 monthly- through my previous employer..
DS has asthma and takes QVAR and Singulair daily. Cash cost both runs about $70 a months (without insurance).
1st option:
$330 monthly premium $6250 deductible $0 coinsurance $50 office visits/ $60 per prenatal visit Prescriptions: no coverage until deductible is met then coinsurance is 0%, 20%
Help me choose... I have to decide by tomorrow. Im leaning towards the high deductible because I feel like I save the difference and easily reach the deductible but it's something about security especially being pregnant and having an toddler with respiratory issues. High deductibles freak me out, I guess.
Wow, nothing in the middle, huh? The way I see it, either way you'll be spending that $6,250 plus some. I would generally choose the better policy, no deductible, but that premium is outrageous so I would get the high deductible plan and also put money in an HSA if that is an option get the pre tax benefit.
I've updated the Max OOP. I was using the numbers from out of network.
But yes, nothing in the middle. Crazy! My employer offers a FSA but no HSA but I guess I can get that on my own since HSA offer more protection than FSA. I'm leaning towards your suggestion because the premium is beyond outrageous even with awesome coverage.
With the $0 deductible plan you'll be paying over 14k for the year. Even with the out of pocket maxes being so different I think I'd still go with the high deductible plan and utilize the HSA like pp suggested. I think you'll save money in long and short game that way. Even if something awful happened and you had a lot of medical bills you can always work out an interest free payment plan with the doctor/hospital. I am by no means an expert regarding medical insurance though, just giving my opinion.
@QueenNub I honestly wasn't sure before you asked, but appears that you may be able to do so. It wouldn't necessarily be pre-tax like it would be through and employer, but you would be able to use it as a deduction. Plus, the money is yours to keep for the future if you don't end up using it healthcare expenses.
Our family premium for a traditional plan was outrageous and unaffordable, so we went the high deductible HSA route. We are only putting $300 in it per month, and even that paired with our premium, we are paying less than 1/2 of the traditional plan's premium.
Thanks ladies! DH is no help with these things and usually goes for the cheapest option. lol I think I'll go with the cheaper premium and save as much as I can for the unexpected. I'll ask about HSA tomorrow.
I would definitely go with the deductible route. Yes, you will pay the $6K but the other way they are cornering you to pay $13K+! Ugh insurance these days is painful
I would go with the high deductible plan. Reason being, you'll save $10,680 a year by going with the cheaper one. That more than makes up for the deductible difference.
TTC 1.0 17 months TTC and 1miscarriage, 1 chemical pregnancy, rainbow baby born 2/16/15 TTC 2.0 16 months TTC, 2 chemical pregnancies, EDD 6/3/17
Hands down option 1. If your employer doesnt offer an HSA you can still open one on your own. The year contribution is $6750.00 which is over your deductible!
Re: Health Insurance
Option 1:
Max OOP: $6350 ind/ $12,700 family
Option 2:
Max OOP: $3250 ind./$6,500 family
But yes, nothing in the middle. Crazy! My employer offers a FSA but no HSA but I guess I can get that on my own since HSA offer more protection than FSA. I'm leaning towards your suggestion because the premium is beyond outrageous even with awesome coverage.
And with your latest numbers update, I stick with my original suggestion of option 1.
Our family premium for a traditional plan was outrageous and unaffordable, so we went the high deductible HSA route. We are only putting $300 in it per month, and even that paired with our premium, we are paying less than 1/2 of the traditional plan's premium.
Reason being, you'll save $10,680 a year by going with the cheaper one. That more than makes up for the deductible difference.
17 months TTC and 1miscarriage, 1 chemical pregnancy, rainbow baby born 2/16/15
TTC 2.0
16 months TTC, 2 chemical pregnancies, EDD 6/3/17
DD2 8.22.13
MMC 1.4.17 at 16w
Expecting #3, EDD 1.29.18