I don't like Brooks at all. Love all your other ideas. Calvin is great and I think it sounds fine with any of the MNs. I also think it goes best with your son's name. Out of your girl names, I like Violet and Leah the most. Ava is pretty popular like you said. Madeline is really nice but I get hung up on the pronunciation issue. Mad-e-lynn vs Mad-e-Line vs Mad-e-leen.
I like Calvin best and think Cal is a great nn.
If Ava is too popular, I'd avoid Madeline too. There are Maddies everywhere. It feels more popular than Ava to me. I love Violet and Leah.
Thank you all for the input! Second guessing Madeline now- it is trendier than I thought I suppose. I still love it though. I've always loved Wyatt but can't get DH on board.
My vote is Madeline as that is my DD's name. We love it and it's not very popular in our area. I'm an elementary teacher and we've only had one Madeline come through our school in the past seven years. I also love Ava and Violet though! June for the middle name.
I don't care for Calvin, probably due to my own associations with the name. I would go with Brooks Michael, although that's NMS either.
Re: Team green name options
I like Violet best of the girl name. I actually prefer the popularity of Ava over any more Maddy/MAddie type names. Leah is nice
Baby #2 Due 3/7/20
Other ideas:
Benjamin
Charles
Ezra
Herbert
James
Jacques
John
Raymond
Richard
Thomas
Victor
Wyatt
Anne
Edith
Eleanor
Esther
Fiona
Juliette
Mae
Maxine
Meredith
Rachel
Rose
Sarah
I don't care for Calvin, probably due to my own associations with the name. I would go with Brooks Michael, although that's NMS either.