I can't decide which name is best - can you please give me your opinions! 

 stuck between Lilah and Georgia. 
I love Georgia and the  fact that She can have multiple nick names , Gia (was one of my top picks but husband wasn't overally in love with it, he loves Georgia though!), Gigi, and Ge. I feel like she has many choices to choose from when she's older - she can choose to go by Georgia or Gia. I'd love to have the choice between those beautiful names. 
I love Lilah - I think it's soft , feminine, unique yet simple in a way! We live in a small town - I've never heard of a Georgia or a Lilah here. Our last name is pronounced "Mack-a-wham" 
Georgia McIlquham
Lilah  McIlquham
Please let me know which one you prefer 
 
                
Re: Stuck between two baby names !
Also there is a board specifically for baby names, maybe you could try there.
I'd go with Lilah.