We are having a hard time. We don't like anything. Modern/trendy names are not our style and all of the traditional classic boy names either bore us to tears or we know too many people with the name (Christopher, Jonathan, Benjamin, Nicholas, Zachary, Matthew, Michael, Thomas, etc., etc., etc.).
Is there a middle ground? Something spunky, fresh, fun, but still a tried and true name? HELP.
We KIND of like Calvin, Arthur, and Gideon but we don't love any of those.

Arden was DH's Grandfather's name but that one has gone to the girls I'm afraid. We like Alden but we don't like the NN "Al".
Middle name will be Tyler after DH. DD is Susannah.
Re: Can we talk BOY names?
Grant
Reid
Micah
Jonah
Leo
Ian
Isaac
Other suggestions:
Atlas
Simon
Wilder
Phineas nn Finn
Blaine
Truman
Porter
Emmett
Francis
Buckley
Langston
Abel
Jude
Ambrose
Baby Boy #1 born 1/9/17
Baby Boy #2 EDD 11/4/18
Warren
Ivan
Gregory
Wesley (this might be getting too trendy?)
Jonas
Orson
Harvey
Leon
Byron
Miles
Julian
Sebastian
And Beckett
I also thought others had good suggestions that went nicely with Tyler, like Warren and Jude. And I have always like Miles, but my husband doesn't. I also loved @2-Step 's suggestion of Grant!