Ok so I slipped (again) and told my sister I am pregnant. Her reaction was...unexpected to say the least. This going to be long, but I just gotta get it all out!
A little background: she is the youngest, single, just turned 25, and is incredible with kids. She is our go-to babysitter and loves our 2yr old son to death! She was super helpful when I first brought him home and was still recovering post emergency CS after a horrendous experience with pre-e (see my intro). She is the only non-nurse in the family so she always feels left out when we talk shop, but she is the most caring of us all.
So, today I was picking up my son after a sleep over with auntie and somehow said something that made my sister joke "What, are you pregnant or something?" and she could tell by my horrible poker face. Then she says "But you weren't planning it, right? So...how does THAT happen?!"
I was mortified. I stammered a lie about birth control pills, but she kept at it. She said "I mean, you are in the same shape you were last time. What are you going to do to make sure you don't get sick again? I thought Renny was going to be an only child! I just don't get how you can accidentally get pregnant again! You have to tell Mom or I will!"
I broke down sobbing and just got my kid and left. But she is coming over tomorrow to help set up my son's birthday party and I just don't know what to do or say. I'm thinking just pretend none of it happened? I am feeling so ashamed and embarrassed because she is right, but also pissed as hell she would say that to me! Just so many emotions right now and I am questioning if this pregnancy is as horrible as she made it out to be.
Tldr: My sister guessed I am pregnant and reacted in the worst possible way. Help!


Re: I am really losing it, guys! Long post...sorry!
I guess you are right that she is just worried, but it was still super hurtful to feel like she was accusing me of something. I hope it all just blows over, but it definitely is making me want to wait as long as possible to tell anyone else!
I'm sure it kind of blindsided you espically since it sounds as if you all are close.
Hugs and I hope you get better reactions from other family members.
Hopefully you can talk about this and not let it drive a wedge between you. This seems like genuine concern to me.
You're ahead of the game this time. You and your doctors will be vigilant for signs of pre-e. And like I mentioned, you can stop it before it starts with medication.
I also think you should talk to your sister again. Tell her you're sorry you lied about your birth control failing, but you became pregnant deliberately, knowing that you're likely to have a perfectly safe delivery this time around. She may be extremely worried about you until the baby is born and she sees for herself that you're ok, but don't leave this lie hanging heavily between you.
Married: Oct 20, 2013
BFP 1: Aug 31, 2015
EDD 1: May 12, 2016
DD1 Emma born May 12, 2016
An Honest Account of New Motherhood (with Postpartum Anxiety, Depression, and OCD)
BFP 2: October 07, 2019
EDD 2: June 20, 2020
If it were me and a family member had a similar reaction I would say something like - "I know what happened last time, there's no guarantee it will or won't happen again but I'm scared too and I could really use your support. What you're doing makes me more anxious and it isn't helpful."
She's coming from a good place, but maybe sharing how her reaction upset you would help and educate her a bit more so she can be supportive instead. Hope you don't have to go through the same thing again!
DS: Born 5-17-16
As PP's said it most likely is coming from a place of worry, not that it makes it right. Maybe mention something to her about what you heard/how you felt when she reacted that way, she may not realize how much her opinion means to you. Like others said, give her the facts about pre-e to educate her but also try to stay confident in the fact that you are an adult and you are in charge of your life. Your sister can have an opinion about your choices, but you and your husband are the only ones who make decisions for your family.
And thanks to you awesome ladies, I have a better perspective and some ideas about how to approach telling her how I feel and explaining in a way that can reassure her that she will still have her big sister as well as another nephew or niece!