Help! My list is growing instead of getting smaller!

ktpaladino · May 2015

So we had it narrowed down to two but your suggestions last week caused us to add some really nice names and made us stumble upon others through a name generator. Can you help us get it narrowed back down? Any names you think I should definitely cross off? Middle name is set- it would be James for all the names except for Keane, which would be paired with Tucker.

Sawyer
Asher
Keane
Gideon
Trevor
Beckett
Maddox
Lucas

benmel31 · May 2015

Asher James!

dramaphile · May 2015

Not a huge fan of Sawyer or Maddox, a bit too trendy for my tastes. Lucas and Asher are my two faves from that list.

MagFranklin13 · May 2015

Gideon James

valeriemarie24 · May 2015

NAF of sawyer or Asher so I'd say Gideon, Trevor or Lucas.
Personally I love the name Trevor, and you don't hear it too often which is nice.

magsugar13 · May 2015

Gideon or Lucas

I think the rest are all pretty bad

wassuphoes · May 2015

Gideon and Lucas

MamaWren919 · May 2015

I still like Sawyer best. Lucas is nice too, but just very popular.

djluschen · May 2015

I like Lucas James

MrsN092714 · May 2015

I love Lucas, Trevor, and Keane!

ClovesA · May 2015

Gideon James. Love it!

ktpaladino · May 2015

Ugh, the hubs just vetoed Gideon and Trevor after looking over the list again because he likes the others so much more. And the more I look at it, I've decided to cross off Beckett and Maddox. So that leaves us with Sawyer, Asher, Keane and Lucas. OK making progress here! Woo hoo!

g8trkim · May 2015

Gideon would be my top choice, but sounds like that's out. Take off Keane because Keane James sounds weird and I immediately though King James. Maddox and Beckett are very Teen Mom. Lucas is nice but pretty popular. Sawyer and Asher are a little on the trendy side but I think they might be your best options.

LizWhiz87 · May 2015

Asher James or Lucas James.

gonetothesea · May 2015

Asher James!

ktpaladino · May 2015

g8trkim said:
Gideon would be my top choice, but sounds like that's out. Take off Keane because Keane James sounds weird and I immediately though King James. Maddox and Beckett are very Teen Mom. Lucas is nice but pretty popular. Sawyer and Asher are a little on the trendy side but I think they might be your best options.

If we decided on Keane, it would be Keane Tucker. (James Tucker is my dad, so drawing from that for the middle name.) I agree Keane James sounds bad which is why we went with Tucker for that one.