I think we've decided on Mara for our baby girl due in May (last name is 3 syllables and starts with 'D'...it's an awkward last name...). My husband really likes Anne as a middle name (after his grandmother). I like it, but I am having trouble with the double A's (marA-Anne). Here are some that I don't mind, but nothing really sticks out to me. Any help would be appreciated - thanks! (BTW - Mara Louise is my favorite because of the way it sounds, but I just don't like the name Louise!)
My cousin is Mara Elizabeth, nn Mara Beth, so that's what sticks out to me the most. I also like PP's suggestion of Mara Elise to give you a feel similar to Louise.
I liked Mara Lucille from your list, it has a similar feel to Louise. I'm also a fan of family named trumping picked-from-a-list names though, and while a lot of times double vowels can kill it for me, I think Mara Anne has a very crisp, neat ring to it.
Re: Middle name for Mara??
Mara Elise
Mara Elaine
Mara Eloise
Mara Cosette
Mara Abigail
Mara Violet
Mara Beatrice
That said, if Mara Anne means a lot to you guys because it is honoring his family, I'd use it anyway. Family significance is important.
As far as just a nice-sounding name, my favorites from above + suggestions are:
Mara Catherine
Mara Claire
Mara Joy
Mara June
Mara Josephine
Mara Pearl
Mara Jewel
Mara Hope