March 2015 Moms

Breast Feeding in Public

drudolph11drudolph11 member
edited December 2014 in March 2015 Moms

So I came across this story while searching for something

https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/montreal/babies-r-us-apologizes-after-breastfeeding-mom-told-to-go-elsewhere-1.2853397

As a FTM who is planning to breast feed it got me thinking about what I would have done in that situation. Now I am in no way what so ever saying that I do not agree with breast feeding in public but personally for me I don't know if I would actually feel comfortable enough with myself and my surroundings to actually do it but who knows I have never been in that situation. I have certainly seen it done plenty of times but some of those times have heard "spectators" remarks about the situation, which are usually not good, from both woman and men and it has totally scared me away from BFing in public. I just always figured if we went out I would either bring milk with me or maybe go somewhere else to BF.

I posted this because I would love to hear from BFing STMs about your experience with it as well as BFing FTMs who are planning to BF what you are planning to do.

ETA: I have actually taken a peek inside those rooms that they had at my local BRU and the one that I saw was very nice. It had a nice glider chair and changing table and extra diapers and wipes sitting out as well as a water heated warmer for bottles and such. I don't recall the room being in the disarray that the room in this story was in but if it was I would most defiantly be deterred from using the room. 

Pregnancy Ticker

imagephoto pgal_zps8d04c926.pngphoto mom2015_zpsb124dd59.pngimage

March 15' January Siggy Callenge: Animals Being Jerks
photo jerks_zpsk4p1dtwb.gif

photo candle_zpslg8yegqf.gif
For @suzyq0525 and all of our other M15 loss moms

Re: Breast Feeding in Public

  • Loading the player...
  • Yea the last person that I saw BFing in public was at Panera. I think I might have stared a little too long lol but it was because I am pregnant, duh lol, and because the way she did it just kinda fascinated me. She didn't have a cover on but I believe she had a nursing tank on, I have never actually seen what one exactly looks like. It just looked like a spaghetti strap shirt. She wasn't large busted and you could tell that she was def nursing but couldn't see anything else at all. It fascinated me just because of how little she had on but still how little you could see. I dunno im still trying to figure it all out. But I am glad to see that NIP isn't an automatic thing that woman are comfortable with lol

    Pregnancy Ticker

    imagephoto pgal_zps8d04c926.pngphoto mom2015_zpsb124dd59.pngimage

    March 15' January Siggy Callenge: Animals Being Jerks
    photo jerks_zpsk4p1dtwb.gif

    photo candle_zpslg8yegqf.gif
    For @suzyq0525 and all of our other M15 loss moms
  • I was really nervous about NIP with DD. I did it, but rarely and always with a cover. Usually I would try to find somewhere private, mostly because it took me a long time to feel like I wasn't fumbling around. I hope it's different with this one. I'm more confident in myself, plus I'll have DD to look after too, and I have a feeling trying to keep her entertained in some small confined space will not be an option. Also, once I started paying attention, i noticed way more moms NIP, which made me feel better about it. It infuriates me when I hear stories like this.
    image
    For Suzy and our M15 Loss Moms
  • I bf wherever I needed to if my daughter was hungry and it was time to nurse. I always used a nursing cover but that was more for my comfort than others. My daughter was used to the cover and it never bothered her- the cover can also help to focus baby and keep older babies from getting distracted. I never had an issue with anyone anywhere. I think most people just assume you are covering baby from the sun, the wind, the cold whatever.

    As pp said it can be tricky to bottle feed if you are out for too long because you will also find that you will need to nurse or will potentially be in a lot of pain/could mess with your supply if you are skipping feedings often enough. Some BF babies also aren't too happy to take a bottle from mom- why take a bottle when they know they can get milk from you.

    It took about a month before I was comforable to NIP (with the cover) but once I was it was very freeing. If you are a nursing mom and feel comfortable NIP you and baby can go anywhere anytime and not have to worry about bringing anything to feed baby.

  • @chunkymonkeylvr that's a good idea! Thinking about it if it was reversed I wouldn't mind someone coming up to me asking me about it. But then again some people aren't as comfortable about it. My mom and I were out the other day at a baby store and saw a woman with her newborn baby, my mom asked her just a few simple questions, like how much did she weigh and if she gave birth at the same hospital I am going to etc., which she answered, begrudgingly, and looked like she could burn us with her eyes, we walked away because she obviously didn't want to talk to us! See with me I know im going to be gushing so much about this baby that I would be more than happy to talk to anyone about her! :) But then come to think about it I guess you never know what someone is going through. Like she could have been dealing with PPD which I can see now why she didn't really feel like talking to us. Didn't really think of that at the time.

    @lynndavid6912 yea it really makes me mad when I hear these stories too cuz I have def heard them in the news before. Because of the smartass that I am if someone were to ever say something to me about it I would prob turn to them and say "oh sorry, well lets just take your meal away until we can a private place for you to eat" haha

    Pregnancy Ticker

    imagephoto pgal_zps8d04c926.pngphoto mom2015_zpsb124dd59.pngimage

    March 15' January Siggy Callenge: Animals Being Jerks
    photo jerks_zpsk4p1dtwb.gif

    photo candle_zpslg8yegqf.gif
    For @suzyq0525 and all of our other M15 loss moms
  • JCWhiteyJCWhitey member
    edited December 2014
    I will BF anywhere and everywhere uncovered.  They are boobs, NBD.  Mine stopped being sexual things the moment I started BFing.  DH wasn't allowed to go anywhere near them!  I've never had any comment about it or say anything to me and I've done it everywhere from stores to restaurants to parks to beaches.  The only place I do not feel comfortable NIP is in church.  I still prefer to go somewhere else to whip it out while there.  I doubt Jesus cares, but it still feels weird to me.

    I think my all time favorite pseudo-NIP story was the time I had a last minute job interview and had to bring DS with me (with the interviewers permission).  He ended up being really cranky in the middle so I told her that if I fed him he would calm down so she told me to go for it.  And so I did.  AND I got the job!  

    I'm happy we live in a time where BFing is supported and there are legal protections given to mothers who choose to BF.  It definitely makes life a lot easier when you don't have to squirrel somewhere to feed.  Once I learned to feed in the carrier that helped a ton, too.  Walking and nursing really saves time.

    ETA: The main reason I chose not to cover at all is because DS has a digestive disorder and would often spit up/choke while nursing and it was easier for me to be able to spot this, lift him, and get him into a position where he wouldn't choke on his own spit-up if he wasn't covered.  That and he started ripping off the cover pretty early, he preferred to look around while eating.  I do not judge anyone who covers at all!  It just wasn't for me.  But whatever you need to be able to comfortably nurse your child DO IT!  

    B born 7/15/13, C born 3/2/15, #3 on the way May '17


    I’m a modern man, a man for the millennium. Digital and smoke free. A diversified multi-cultural, post-modern deconstruction that is anatomically and ecologically incorrect. I’ve been up linked and downloaded, I’ve been inputted and outsourced, I know the upside of downsizing, I know the downside of upgrading. I’m a high-tech low-life. A cutting edge, state-of-the-art bi-coastal multi-tasker and I can give you a gigabyte in a nanosecond! I’m new wave, but I’m old school and my inner child is outward bound. I’m a hot-wired, heat seeking, warm-hearted cool customer, voice activated and bio-degradable. I interface with my database, my database is in cyberspace, so I’m interactive, I’m hyperactive and from time to time I’m radioactive.

  • @jessuhmarie so with the t-shirt/tank combo, do you mean you would pull the tank down underneath and then put her under your t-shirt as a cover?

    @bostonchelle & @happymamax2 that def does make sense why taking the bottles with us would be a hassle. I never even though about the logistics of the situation lol I would def love to get to the point where I am comfortable BFing in public even if it is always with a cover. I mean I feel as though if I am committing to BFing then this is just something that goes along with it. Im just praying that she doesn't have too much of a problem taking to a bottle because once I go back to work (about 6-8 weeks) then my mom or SO will have her and will have to feed her from a bottle. We just purchased the Kiinde Twistii System because this seemed like the most efficient way to make that situation easier on everyone. So this is what I had in my mind we would take with us during our outings but totally forgot the heating up aspect of it. lol Eh we will see what happens I suppose. If all else fails I will go out to the car or somewhere private until I am comfortable enough with NIP!

    Pregnancy Ticker

    imagephoto pgal_zps8d04c926.pngphoto mom2015_zpsb124dd59.pngimage

    March 15' January Siggy Callenge: Animals Being Jerks
    photo jerks_zpsk4p1dtwb.gif

    photo candle_zpslg8yegqf.gif
    For @suzyq0525 and all of our other M15 loss moms
  • @jcwhitey ok that makes sense now. What I had in my head was having the top tank like totally up over the whole baby lol
    Pregnancy Ticker

    imagephoto pgal_zps8d04c926.pngphoto mom2015_zpsb124dd59.pngimage

    March 15' January Siggy Callenge: Animals Being Jerks
    photo jerks_zpsk4p1dtwb.gif

    photo candle_zpslg8yegqf.gif
    For @suzyq0525 and all of our other M15 loss moms
  • Well, I nursed both my kids until they were toddlers, and I also tried to get out of the house and have a life as much as possible, so I did NIP a lot (less so as they got older and nursed less frequently).  I never had an issue with it and did it wherever I needed to.  I think everyone has their own way of managing to do it at their own comfort level.  I usually didn't bother with nursing tanks or covers or anything because I was able just to lift up my shirt and tuck the kid underneath without feeling like anything was exposed.  Probably depends a lot on boob size, body shape, how your clothes fit, how squirmy your baby is, etc., but it worked for me.
    DD born 10/10/07 * DS born 11/25/11 * #3 due 3/9/2015
  • BF vs FF both have their pros and cons but I agree that formula has never felt that convenient to me.  My cousin FF and we were having breakfast one morning and her daughter was hungry so she decided to make her a bottle, but had to ask the waiter for a class of hot water to heat the bottle, take the time to heat it (while her daughter was hungry and crying), then had to let it cool because they over heated it.  Meanwhile when DS got hungry I just fed him.  But BFing can also have its inconveniences.  I swear I'd get mastitis anytime I had an important test or job interview.

    B born 7/15/13, C born 3/2/15, #3 on the way May '17


    I’m a modern man, a man for the millennium. Digital and smoke free. A diversified multi-cultural, post-modern deconstruction that is anatomically and ecologically incorrect. I’ve been up linked and downloaded, I’ve been inputted and outsourced, I know the upside of downsizing, I know the downside of upgrading. I’m a high-tech low-life. A cutting edge, state-of-the-art bi-coastal multi-tasker and I can give you a gigabyte in a nanosecond! I’m new wave, but I’m old school and my inner child is outward bound. I’m a hot-wired, heat seeking, warm-hearted cool customer, voice activated and bio-degradable. I interface with my database, my database is in cyberspace, so I’m interactive, I’m hyperactive and from time to time I’m radioactive.

  • FrecklesInside said, it's not easy to pump and bring bottles. She mentioned several of the issues but also, what do you do with the milk in your boobs? If you don't nurse or pump you are going to get engorged. You could diminish supply if you skipped nursing regularly. It is really quite simple to nip but, like others mentioned, it took me a few weeks to a month to get it figured out or get the guts to do it.
    BabyFruit Ticker


  • I'm also team bf in public. The first few months of DD's life I fed on demand, and meant some of those times to bf in public. I would either bf in my car, or a secluded place. Either using a cover or a long scarf. I think I used a bathroom once, and it was disgusting.

    image image
    imageimage
  • My plan is to bf, I have really wondered what my comfort would be. I don't tend to be too modest, I'm pretty comfortable with my body & I don't see myself tolerating my baby being uncomfortable or hungry for the sake of strangers- but I haven't done it yet so I have no idea how I'll feel. I do 100% support any mother in feeding her child however she feels most appropriate.

    I am planning to go back to work 3 days a week & I feel like pumping will be more anxiety inducing for me. I do home based ABA- most days I'm in and out of people's houses & in my car. I feel like that will be harder than in an office with an established routine. At least my car is a pretty private place.
  • People bitch no matter what you do.  My first outing with DD (who was maybe 2 weeks) I wasn't comfortable NIP so I elected to go to the family restroom.  Another customer (male) banged on the door and threatened to get management since I was taking so long.  It was so uncomfortable and embarrassing.
    Image and video hosting by TinyPic image
  • I nursed both of mine in public, and like some of the PP's most people wouldn't have noticed. I would use a cover sometimes, but as they get more aware it's moot b/c they both would pull it off it down anyways.

    In AZ and TX it's illegal to tell a nursing mom she can't nurse.
    Good to know!
  • kcbizme said:



    I nursed both of mine in public, and like some of the PP's most people wouldn't have noticed. I would use a cover sometimes, but as they get more aware it's moot b/c they both would pull it off it down anyways.

    In AZ and TX it's illegal to tell a nursing mom she can't nurse.

    Good to know!

    This is true in most places, I believe. I know in Ohio, mom has the right to BF anywhere she would otherwise have the right to be. I think there's a website somewhere that has the laws by state...
    image
    For Suzy and our M15 Loss Moms
  • I fully intend to NIP but I hadn't really considered the possibility of crowded places being too distracting for LO to latch and focus. I guess if we have problems and have to find a quiet private place that is what we will do. 

    Do you think that if you NIP with a very little one they are more likely to be able to NIP later?

    Also, I read this article this morning of Breastfeeding as a reproductive health issue, which isn't a context in which people normally speak about breastfeeding. I found it insightful and interesting. Ina May Gaskin shared it on facebbok so some of you may have already seen it.


    BabyFruit Ticker
  • Carmar3 said:

    My favorite "comeback" for neigh-sayers was always, " what the hell do you think boobs were made for?"

    I'm totally gonna remember this one and use it as needed.
  • I nursed my son in public until he was 2. Without a cover. I always layered a nursing tank with another shirt so you wouldn't be able to see anything but the back of his head.

    Honestly? It was no big deal. I know lots of people have horror stories about being treated unfairly, but I never got more than a raised eyebrow. I received way more positive comments and questions than anything else.

    Once your kid is here and you hear your baby crying, it can be a lot easier to set aside your apprehension about NIP because you know baby needs to eat or be comforted and you have everything you need to do that.

    BabyFruit Ticker

    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker

  • tatilopeztatilopez member
    edited December 2014
    I've witnessed a lot of family members and friends who have breast fed their children and I've been with them and to be honest when that baby is yelping and screaming bcuz he or she is hungry breaking those boobs out is a natural thing. Were so wrapped up into bottles being the go to thing but our breast are their bottles! I don't remember me frowning at a dog or cat feeding their offspring so why is it so mind blowing when humans do it? Also ppl need to get a damn grip! Why is your mind in the gutter when u see someone breast feeding! Like seriously people it's a baby and a tit get over yourself!
  • I nursed my son wherever. I didn't use a cover but I never found my boobs were all out everywhere. Most people wouldn't even really be able to tell I was nursing just walking by. I never once had people say things expect a few creepy old dudes saying "I'll have what he's having." Ewwwwww!!!! Lol
  • If I had to NIP, I totally would have. I didn't take LO many public places when she was a young infant and when she was older (starting about 5-6 months) she was such a distractible nurser I COULDN'T nurse in public. But it would've been so much more convenient. If you don't feel comfortable, you can always try using a cover or baby wear and discreetly nurse that way.
  • I wish I was able to BF in public with my first child. She never took and I had to pump and bottle feed her every time. For me, I would do it in public just for the celebration of how beautiful it is and the triumph of actually being able to offer this amazing gift to my child. It hurt me so much that I couldn't feed my daughter naturally the first time. I plan to BF my son in public when needed, if he takes to the nip.
    I follow this group on FB, it's titled breastfeeding moms, I think. I highly recommend following them. Good reads and advice.
  • I am team NIP!  I nursed my son for 9 months, only quitting b/c PPD/PPA was ruining my life.  I'm lucky to say I had enough milk as several cows, so I know I could have reached my year goal.  I still get bummed I never hit the goal I intended to, but I I tried! I nursed him in public, with a nursing cover b/c at that time that is what I was most comfortable doing.  I will feel more comfortable this time around though.  If she doesn't like a cover, oh well...
    PPD/PPA Mom...it has been super hard, but I'm making it! Slow steps...
    Mom to Carter (6), and Calianne (1).  
    Proud VBAC, natural birth, breastfeeding, cloth diapering momma!


This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards
"
"