What is your favorite pie traditionally served on Thanksgiving? Choose by main ingredient; if caramel apple walnut is your favorite, vote apple and describe in the comments!
5 cycles of "TTC" - 3 intentional, 2 not so intentional. 5 BFPs. My rainbow arrived 10/15/14. TFMC 08.02.13 at 19+ weeks. Everyday I grieve for my little Olive.
THE GREAT PI POLE!! 133 votes
Pumpkin - with or without whipped cream? Streusel or no streusel?
38%51 votes
Sweet potato - Moonlights as a side dish, what more could you want?
0%1 vote
Apple - YA 'MURICA!!!!
20%27 votes
Pecan - I don't care how you pronounce it, give me the sweet brown sugar and pecans!
18%25 votes
Blueberry- Reminds me of summer! (I was between blueberry and cherry, but blueberry seems more popular in winter)
0%0 votes
Buttermilk / Butter - I had no idea this existed, but apparently it's a regional delicacy!
1%2 votes
Key lime / Lemon Meringue - Tart + sweet = my favorite treat!
I was tied between pumpkin and pecan. But since DH doesn't like pumpkin pie, I rarely get it. So, my favorite pecan pie is a combination of chocolate pecan pie and bourbon pecan pie.
Married 10/06
Baby Girl "C" arrived on 10/07/14 (39 weeks, 6 days)
Gooseberry, made with a tart cherry pie recipe. I had some in a restaurant once and it was way too sweet.
Do you make it too? Where do you buy them? I can't find gooseberries anywhere but Amazon. :-??
It's been a few years since I've made one, but I had to have my grandmother send me a few cans from Indiana last time. We used to be able to find them at No Frills. I haven't looked this year because I don't have time to bake it.
I like pumpkin for holidays and cherry the rest of the time. Pie must always be served warm with ice cream. If you can't serve it warm, it's not pie, it's pudding on crust.
Pumpkin with tons of homemade vanilla whipped cream!! Or homemade banana cream with a graham cracker crust and vanilla whipped cream. We always have 3 pies, because of course we also need to have apple pie!
By the way, Cool Whip is a crime against humanity. Home made whipped cream all the way!!
Cool whip shouldn't exist.
What?! I would eat a big tub of cool whip with a spoon if I could without feeling like a huge slob. But I've also never had homemade. I'm sure I wouldn't turn it down.
5 cycles of "TTC" - 3 intentional, 2 not so intentional. 5 BFPs. My rainbow arrived 10/15/14. TFMC 08.02.13 at 19+ weeks. Everyday I grieve for my little Olive.
Gooseberry, made with a tart cherry pie recipe. I had some in a restaurant once and it was way too sweet.
Do you make it too? Where do you buy them? I can't find gooseberries anywhere but Amazon. :-??
It's been a few years since I've made one, but I had to have my grandmother send me a few cans from Indiana last time. We used to be able to find them at No Frills. I haven't looked this year because I don't have time to bake it.
Banana creme pie. The best pie on the planet and we used to get it from Marie calendar ' s when I was growing up but they closed all their locations near us a few years ago.
So if you like pecans and you like chocolate you need chocolate pecan pie in your life now. Emeril has a recipe it's called golden brick chocolate pecan pie. I swear when I eat it the heavens open up and I hear angels singing
Re: THE GREAT PI POLE!!
Married 10/06
Baby Girl "C" arrived on 10/07/14 (39 weeks, 6 days)
Emma Rose - 9.14.05 Beckett - 5.26.07 Sawyer - 9.22.12 Lennon Mae - 9.26.14
GIVE ME ALL PIE.
My Ovulation Chart Simple Link: My Ovulation Chart
TFMC 08.02.13 at 19+ weeks. Everyday I grieve for my little Olive.
Alexander Flynn ~ September 24, 2014
Married 8/27/2011
BFP #1 9/28/2011 DS born 5/22/2012
BFP #2 4/24/2013 m/c 4/25/2013 at 4w
BFP #3 1/31/2014 DD born 10/14/2014
BFP #4 1/20/2016 m/c 2/12/2014 at 7w2d
BFP #5 8/19/2016 DS2 born 4/29/2017
BFP #6 3/7/2018 EDD 11/18/2018
My vote is for Pumpkin. Mmmmm... warm, with whipped cream.