Stay at Home Moms

WWYD re: Apartment. Is this legal?

Some background. We have lived in the same apartment building for 4 years now. It's a dog apartment building and overall we've loved our rental agency and our place.

About two years ago, we had trash cans outside each set of doors. One day they were gone so we called and asked where they had gone, because duh dogs poop and we need somewhere to put it. They told us that someone was defacing the trash cans so they took them out. I asked if it was at our building cause ours had looked fine and they said no, but they decided to take them all out anyways. Ok, that makes sense, it's annoying, but whatever.

Earlier this year in May, we signed a new year long lease. Shortly after that, there were signs on the doors that people weren't picking up dog poop. We got extra vigilant after that picking up ALL poop around the building because they said that there would be consequences if it didn't changed.

Fast forward to now, all summer long we've taken the dogs out and picked poop up. We walk around the building daily trying to get our damn dogs to poop so we see all of the yard. There's no poop anywhere. Last week, they put up a sign that tomorrow all dogs will be DNA tested and a fifty dollar fee will be billed to tenants with dogs.

A) This wasn't in our contract to begin with so both DH and I feel we shouldn't have to pay as there was no warning to do this.
B) Our apartment yard (around our whole building) is clean and free of poop. There are about 5 dogs in the building and all of out neighbors are wonderful about picking up their dog's waste.

It seems like this is another buildings problem so like the trash can incident, they're making it the same across the board for everyone. Ok well, maybe you should wait to put that in the contract when people renew it. Can they honestly just changed stuff mid contract and say you have to pay 'x'? I'm not sure what our contract says on this because I can't find it in our stack of leases for the past 4 years (I have every other year'a lease though). I'm going to be stopping by and asking them for a print out of our lease agreement so I can double check what it says, but I was wondering what you guys thought?
BFP #1: DD born on 08.25.12 BFP #2: 09/08/15 miscarried at 6w BFP #3: DD2 born on 02.07.17

Re: WWYD re: Apartment. Is this legal?

  • I'm gonna go with no, they can't force you.
  • Loading the player...
  • fintinfintin member
    edited October 2014
    Since it was not in the original lease they can't charge you this fee. They can add it to future leases or releases but they can not make people pay a fee that was not in the present lease. I would fight this.
  • Kimbus22 said:

    I fail to see what this would accomplish.  Are the yards of the buildings entirely fenced in?  Because how do they even know it's dogs that live there?

    That's the thing, none of them are fenced in, but our particular building we always walk around and make sure there's no poop at our building in particular. I guess they have noticed it's a reoccurring problem at one of the other buildings and are now forcing all tenants with dogs to comply.

    It's not billed at the time of the DNA testing, but later. I'm tempted to make a copy of our lease and take the bill and mail it to them. Fucking assholes.
    BFP #1: DD born on 08.25.12 BFP #2: 09/08/15 miscarried at 6w BFP #3: DD2 born on 02.07.17
  • I wouldn't pay either, especially if the yard isn't fenced in at all.
  • You never signed stating you will pay so you don't pay. That was not the agreement.
    image

    Check out my blog ---->  http://minismama.com/
  • The yard not being fenced in is an AWESOME point that I didn't even think about. I'll have to bring that up when I talk to the person dealing with all this. She's conviently "out of the office", but I'm more than welcome to leave her a voicemail.
    BFP #1: DD born on 08.25.12 BFP #2: 09/08/15 miscarried at 6w BFP #3: DD2 born on 02.07.17
  • Leave her a flaming bag on her doorstep instead of a voicemail. Tell her to DNA test THAT and charge you. Lol, how ridiculous.
  • I have never heard of such a thing!  I definitely would not pay that, because it is not in your lease agreement. Also, if you are being vigilant and your building is clean, it should hopefully be a non-issue. Good luck!
This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards
"
"